| 100% | WALUIGI | 7 | Purple-clad character who serves as a foil to Mario's brother in the "Super Mario Bros." series |
| 39% | ART | 3 | ___ Vandelay, recurring fake "Seinfeld" character who appears as a real judge in the series finale |
| 38% | ROSALINA | 8 | Magical character in the Super Mario games who wears a turquoise dress with a silver crown |
| 38% | ORA | 3 | Rita ___, singer who served as a judge on the show "The X Factor" in series 12 |
| 38% | TOADETTE | 8 | Childlike character in the Super Mario games who wears a pink dress with a pink mushroom hat |
| 38% | PRINCESSPEACH | 13 | Royal character in the Super Mario games who wears a pink dress with a gold crown: 2 wds. |
| 37% | PERSEPHONE | 10 | Goddess who serves as a major character in 2019's "Hadestown" |
| 37% | LUIGI | 5 | Character kidnapped by Bowser in The Super Mario Bros. Movie |
| 36% | ILSA | 4 | Character who says “Kiss me as if it were the last time” to Rick, in a 1942 film |
| 36% | EMCEE | 5 | "Cabaret" character who acts as a host to the audience |
| 36% | PEACH | 5 | Princess named after a fruit, in the Super Mario Bros. franchise |
| 36% | REA | 3 | Actor Stephen who is portrayed as a character in the 2024 historical drama series “Say Nothing” |
| 35% | LUIGI | 5 | Mario's brother in the popular video game series |
| 35% | TOAD | 4 | Super Mario Bros. character who resembles a mushroom |
| 34% | TOAD | 4 | Super Mario Bros. character who looks like a mushroom |
| 34% | ALCOTT | 6 | Best-selling author who served as a nurse in the Civil War |
| 34% | LUNA | 4 | ___ Lovegood, character in the "Harry Potter" series who was a part of Dumbledore's Army |
| 34% | CHO | 3 | ___ Chang, character in the "Harry Potter" series who was a part of Dumbledore's Army |
| 34% | HAGRID | 6 | Robbie Coltrane's character in the "Harry Potter" series who sports a distinctive bushy beard |
| 34% | CHRISPRATT | 10 | "Guardians of the Galaxy" actor who voices Mario in "The Super Mario Bros. Movie" (2 wds.) |
| 34% | JOHN | 4 | ___ Leguizamo, "Super Mario Bros." actor who portrays the role of a Movie Star in "The Menu" |
| 34% | IAGO | 4 | Parrot who serves as a sidekick for Jafar in the Disney animated film "Aladdin" |
| 33% | LUIGI | 5 | Plumber character who is Mario's twin brother and sidekick in the video game franchise |
| 33% | CHARLIEDAY | 10 | "It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia" actor who voices Luigi in "The Super Mario Bros. Movie" (2 wds.) |
| 33% | ROBRIGGLE | 9 | "Holey Moley" color commentator who served as a public affairs officer in the Marines: 2 wds. |
| 33% | KOOLAIDMAN | 10 | Character who bursts through a window to join a stampede of wiener dogs in a 2025 Super Bowl ad |
| 33% | SIR | 3 | ___ Hiss, snake who serves as a henchman for Prince John in the Disney animated film "Robin Hood" |
| 32% | BETTYCOOPER | 11 | The sweet, blonde girl next door character from "Riverdale," who serves as a protagonist and is played by Lili Reinhart |
| 32% | WARPPIPE | 8 | Piece of plumbing used to travel to a different area, in Super Mario Bros. |
| 32% | REGULARS | 8 | Main actors in a continuing series, as opposed to the show's guest stars |