| 100% | CROSSWORD | 9 | Puzzle like this! |
| 88% | THEMED | 6 | Like this puzzle |
| 88% | CLUED | 5 | Like this puzzle |
| 86% | EASY | 4 | Like this puzzle ... not! |
| 86% | THEMED | 6 | Like this crossword puzzle |
| 85% | CROSS | 5 | What words do in a puzzle like this one |
| 85% | ASYMMETRIC | 10 | Like this puzzle's grid |
| 85% | WHOLLYTHEMELESS | 15 | Like this puzzle? (not really) |
| 85% | SOLVABLE | 8 | Like this puzzle, we hope |
| 85% | HAUNTED | 7 | Like this puzzle's theme? |
| 85% | SOLVABLE | 8 | Like this puzzle, I hope |
| 83% | NONINTERLOCKING | 15 | Like this puzzle's 37-Across |
| 83% | CHOCKABLOCK | 11 | Full, like this puzzle |
| 82% | SIXWORD | 7 | Like this puzzle's story, in length |
| 80% | OVOID | 5 | Shaped like this puzzle's subject |
| 79% | PERSONALIZED | 12 | Like this puzzle, when 36-Across is filled in |
| 79% | SOLVED | 6 | Like this puzzle, when you're finished with it |
| 79% | MAKESSENSE | 10 | Adds up ... like this puzzle's theme? |
| 79% | LIVINGONTHEEDGE | 15 | Acting dangerously, like this puzzle's subject |
| 77% | NOTUPTOPAR | 10 | Like the duffer in this puzzle? |
| 76% | OAKLANDAS | 9 | California baseball team that would probably like this puzzle |
| 76% | ACROSS | 6 | Like many of this puzzle's answers |
| 76% | ACROSS | 6 | Like 36 of this puzzle's answers |
| 75% | LOSTINTHESHUFFLE | 16 | Like this puzzle's circled letters vis-à-vis their Across answers |
| 75% | THETIESTHATBIND | 15 | Shared beliefs ... like this puzzle's circled four-letter words? |
| 74% | RATEDNC17 | 9 | Like the film "Henry & June" (and this puzzle) |
| 74% | MISPELLED | 9 | Like the six longest answers in this puzzle |
| 74% | PERSONAL | 8 | Like the 52-Across featured in this puzzle |
| 74% | THEMED | 6 | Like many crossword puzzles (though not this one) |
| 74% | ITSABOUTNOTHING | 15 | Why this puzzle is like "Seinfeld"? |