| 100% | BUTTERBEER | 10 | Quaff at the Three Broomsticks inn |
| 45% | NOROOM | 6 | What there was at the inn |
| 43% | STAY | 4 | Time at the inn |
| 41% | TRI | 3 | Three at the start |
| 41% | NEWHART | 7 | TV series set at the Stratford Inn |
| 41% | RIOTS | 5 | Pivotal 1969 events at the Stonewall Inn |
| 40% | EMBER | 5 | It glows at the end of three months |
| 40% | ETA | 3 | Letter at the end of three other letters |
| 40% | EMBER | 5 | It flickers at the end of three months |
| 40% | POINTSTATEPARK | 14 | Pittsburgh landmark at the confluence of three rivers |
| 40% | TREVI | 5 | Italian fountain at the junction of three roads |
| 39% | EMBER | 5 | It's hot at the end of three months |
| 39% | EMBER | 5 | It’s hot at the end of three months |
| 39% | STEELCITY | 9 | Metropolitan area at the junction of three rivers, familiarly |
| 39% | RIOT | 4 | Historic event that happened at the Stonewall Inn in 1969 |
| 37% | EARPS | 5 | Three fighters at the O.K. Corral |
| 37% | MENTALGYMNASTICS | 16 | Complex reasoning that occurs literally at the end of three long answers |
| 37% | AFTER | 5 | Quarter ___ (when the big hand is at three) |
| 36% | EXPLODE | 7 | Appropriate playlist title for the three songs at 15-, 28-, and 33-Across |
| 36% | TRIPLETS | 8 | Three siblings born at the same time |
| 36% | TOGETHER | 8 | Three got moved at the same time |
| 36% | BLT | 3 | Three ingredient sandwich at the deli: Abbr. |
| 36% | HALLE | 5 | ___ Berry, actress with roles found at the starts of three answers in this puzzle |
| 35% | IMITATIONOFLIFE | 15 | 1934 Oscar-nominated film whose title hints at the wordplay in three other long answers |
| 35% | DROPDOWNMENU | 12 | Options at the top of a computer window … as seen three times in this puzzle? |
| 35% | KEEPERS | 7 | Professionals at inns who may cook, clean, and manage the establishment |
| 34% | SAMSNEAD | 8 | Three-time Masters winner who wrote the memoir "Golf Begins at Forty" (2 wds.) |
| 34% | SIDES | 5 | The “three” at a meat-and-three joint |
| 33% | ACHORUSLINE | 11 | Broadway musical about three guys using the same pickup routine at a bar? |
| 33% | TENORS | 6 | The Three ___ |