| 100% | RAYJ | 4 | Rapper and reality-TV star whose real name is William Norwood, Jr. |
| 44% | BONO | 4 | Rock star whose real name is Paul Hewson |
| 44% | BONO | 4 | Irish rock star whose real name is Paul Hewson |
| 44% | CMPUNK | 6 | '00s pro wrestling star whose real name is Phil Brooks |
| 43% | THEUNDERTAKER | 13 | WWE wrestler whose real name is Mark William Calaway and who has more pay-per-view victories than any other WWE wrestler: 2 wds. |
| 42% | MACKLEMORE | 10 | Rapper whose real name is Ben Haggerty |
| 42% | DRAKE | 5 | Rapper whose real name is Aubrey Graham |
| 42% | EMINEM | 6 | Rapper whose real name is Marshall Mathers |
| 42% | ICET | 4 | Rapper whose real name is Tracy Marrow: Hyph. |
| 41% | ICET | 4 | Rapper and "Law & Order: SVU" star whose birth name is Tracy Marrow: Hyph. |
| 40% | ALF | 3 | Furry '80s TV alien whose real name was Gordon Shumway |
| 40% | FUTURE | 6 | The rapper whose real name is Nayvadius Wilburn |
| 40% | OZZYOSBOURNE | 12 | Heavy metal singer and reality TV star who is "catching some Z's": 2 wds. |
| 39% | PSI | 3 | DC Comics character whose real name is Gayle Marsh and who can trigger incapacitating fear in people |
| 38% | GLEE | 4 | TV show whose fandom name is a portmanteau of its title and “geeks” |
| 38% | MCHAMMER | 8 | Early '90s rapper whose real name is Stanley Burrell |
| 37% | REYMYSTERIO | 11 | WWE wrestler whose real name is Oscar Gutierrez and regarded as the greatest cruiserweight wrestler of all time: 2 wds. |
| 37% | FLORIDA | 7 | Rapper and singer whose name comes from the state he was born in: 2 wds. |
| 35% | STING | 5 | Singer whose real name is Gordon Sumner |
| 35% | DOE | 3 | John ___ (man whose real name is unknown) |
| 35% | RIHANNA | 7 | Singer whose real name is Robyn Fenty |
| 35% | DOE | 3 | Jane ___ (woman whose real name is unknown) |
| 35% | BATMAN | 6 | Superhero whose real name is Bruce Wayne |
| 35% | REN | 3 | Kylo whose real name is Ben Solo |
| 35% | SHIV | 4 | Succession character whose real name is Siobhan |
| 35% | YODA | 4 | Baby ___ (character whose real name is Grogu) |
| 35% | KEEL | 4 | Actor-singer whose real name was Leek |
| 35% | FONZ | 4 | 1970's TV character whose real first name was Arthur, with "the" |
| 35% | BONO | 4 | Irish rocker whose real name is Paul Hewson |
| 35% | PENGUIN | 7 | Batman villain whose real name is Oswald Cobblepot |