| 100% | DAYO | 4 | Refrain word in the song with the lyric "Come, Mister Tally Man, tally me banana" |
| 50% | DAYO | 4 | "Come, Mister Tally Man, tally me banana" song |
| 44% | ITHURTSOBAD | 11 | Susan Tedeschi song with the lyric "You were the best man I ever had" |
| 42% | LAYLA | 5 | Clapton song with the lyric “Like a fool, I fell in love with you” |
| 42% | EVERLONG | 8 | Foo Fighters song with the lyric "Breathe out, so I can breathe you in" |
| 42% | LAYLA | 5 | Eric Clapton song with the lyric "Like a fool, I fell in love with you" |
| 42% | HELPME | 6 | Joni Mitchell song with the lyric “I think I’m falling in love too fast” |
| 42% | INVISIBLE | 9 | 52-Across song with the lyric "Then I could just watch you in your room" |
| 41% | CIRCUS | 6 | Britney Spears song with the lyric "All the eyes on me in the center of the ring" |
| 41% | MAPS | 4 | Maroon 5 hit song with the lyric "When all the roads you took came back to me" |
| 41% | MOONRIVER | 9 | Song with the lyric "I'm crossing you in style someday" |
| 40% | SHILO | 5 | Neil Diamond song with the lyrics "When I was young / I used to call your name / When no one else would come" |
| 40% | ALTEREGO | 8 | Doechii song with the lyrics "I come through and moods be switchin' / I'm the problem, I'm the villain" |
| 40% | TRUE | 4 | Spandau Ballet song with the lyrics "I bought a ticket to the world / But now I've come back again" |
| 40% | JIMMYCRACKCORN | 14 | Old song with the lyric "When he would ride in the afternoon / I'd follow him with my hickory broom" |
| 40% | CENTERFIELD | 11 | John Fogerty song about baseball with the lyrics "Put me in coach, I'm ready to play today" |
| 40% | ODNIGHTIRENE | 12 | Classic song with the lyric "I'll see you in my dreams" |
| 40% | TRUE | 4 | Spandau Ballet hit song with the lyrics "I bought a ticket to the world / But now I've come back again" |
| 39% | ITSYOU | 6 | Song from "The Music Man" with the lyric "What words could be saner or truer or plainer" |
| 39% | SUNDAYMORNING | 13 | Maroon 5 song with the lyric "Come and rest your bones with me" (2 wds.) |
| 39% | THEREFOREIAM | 12 | Song with the lyric "You think that you're the man / I think ... " on 43-Across's new album, "Happier Than Ever" (3 wds.) |
| 39% | SHILO | 5 | Neil Diamond song with the lyrics, "When I was young / I used to call your name / When no one else would come" |
| 39% | DANCINGQUEEN | 12 | 39-Down song with the lyrics "Where they play the right music, getting in the swing / You come to look for a king" |
| 39% | EBAY | 4 | Weird Al song with the lyrics "Gonna buy (some Beanie Babies, new with tag) / (From some guy) I've never met in Norway" |
| 39% | MAINSTREET | 10 | Top 40 song by 46-Across with the lyrics "I drift back in time and I find my feet" |
| 39% | HEREWITHME | 10 | 2019 hit song by 17-Down featuring Chvrches with the lyrics "You're saying the words that I want you to say / There's a pain in my heart and it won't go away" (3 wds.) |
| 39% | MISTLETOE | 9 | Justin Bieber holiday song with the lyrics "I should be playin' in the winter snow" |
| 39% | EBAY | 4 | "Weird Al" Yankovic song with the lyrics "Gonna buy some Beanie Babies, new with tag / From some guy I've never met in Norway" |
| 39% | EBAY | 4 | "Weird Al" Yankovic song with the lyrics "Gonna buy (some Beanie Babies, new with tag) / (From some guy) I've never met in Norway" |
| 38% | CCRIDER | 7 | 1950s-'60s hit with the lyric "Ah, you made me love you / Now, now, now, now your man is come" |