| 100% | IMALITTLETEAPOT | 15 | Rhyming song that's acted out |
| 54% | EARWORM | 7 | Song that's hard to get out of your head |
| 49% | EVERLONG | 8 | Song that rhymes with "song" |
| 47% | RESPECTLESSNIGHT | 16 | Karaoke outing that won't allow Aretha's classic song? |
| 47% | ANTHEM | 6 | Song that gets a rise out of fans |
| 45% | BORN | 4 | "___ to Run" (Bruce Springsteen song that closed out Jon Stewart's tenure on "The Daily Show") |
| 45% | YANKEE | 6 | "___ Doodle," popular nursery rhyme song that is the state song of Connecticut |
| 44% | ROCKLOBSTER | 11 | Novelty B-52's song with the lyric "Watch out for that piranha" |
| 43% | OLDIE | 5 | Song that's not recent |
| 43% | HYMN | 4 | Song that's sung in church |
| 43% | ARIA | 4 | Song that's Italian for "air" |
| 42% | GOOSEEGGS | 9 | Joanna Newsom song title that’s rhymed with the lyric “loose legs” |
| 42% | HIT | 3 | Song that's high on the charts |
| 42% | DEEPCUT | 7 | Song that's only familiar to superfans |
| 42% | CAROL | 5 | Song that's typically sung in December |
| 42% | MIME | 4 | One who's acting out? |
| 42% | ONCUE | 5 | Acting out the line at the exact moment, that was pre-decided : 2 wds. |
| 41% | PORGIE | 6 | "Georgie ___" (nursery rhyme that inspired a Toto song) |
| 41% | SOLO | 4 | Song that's sung by just one person |
| 41% | ARIA | 4 | Song that's often in a foreign language |
| 41% | SMASHHIT | 8 | Song that's a huge success: 2 wds. |
| 41% | OLDIE | 5 | Song that's a blast from the past |
| 40% | CONGA | 5 | Dance that a Gloria Estefan song rhymes with "longer" |
| 40% | HELLO | 5 | Adele song that's also a greeting |
| 40% | ILOVETRASH | 10 | "Sesame Street" song that's complete rubbish? |
| 40% | CRIME | 5 | Act that breaks the law, and a word that rhymes with "time" |
| 39% | OMG | 3 | Usher song that's also a texting abbreviation |
| 39% | MASH | 4 | "Monster ___" (1962 song that's popular around Halloween) |
| 39% | EARWORM | 7 | Song that gets stuck in one's head |
| 39% | MONSTERMASH | 11 | Classic Halloween song that’s “a graveyard smash” |