| 100% | BARABBAS | 8 | Robber in the New Testament released at the Passover instead of Jesus |
| 43% | BARTHOLOMEW | 11 | One of the Twelve Apostles of Jesus in the New Testament; patron saint of tanners |
| 41% | APOSTLE | 7 | One of 12 in the New Testament |
| 41% | FOUR | 4 | Number of Gospels in the New Testament |
| 40% | PHARISEES | 9 | With Scribes in the New Testament, opposed Jesus |
| 40% | SCRIBES | 7 | With Pharisees in the New Testament, opposed Jesus |
| 40% | LUKE | 4 | Author of the third Gospel in the New Testament |
| 40% | MATTHEW | 7 | Author of the first Gospel in the New Testament |
| 40% | MATTHEW | 7 | First of the four Gospels in the New Testament |
| 40% | ZEBEDEE | 7 | Father of James and John in the New Testament |
| 40% | ELIZABETH | 9 | Name of Mary's sister in the New Testament |
| 39% | LAZARUS | 7 | Raised from the dead by Jesus in the New Testament |
| 39% | CAIAPHAS | 8 | Jewish high priest in the New Testament; son-in-law of Annas |
| 38% | APOLLYON | 8 | Greek name of The Destroyer in Revelation 9:11 in the New Testament |
| 38% | BUFFALO | 7 | US port in New York State at the eastern end of Lake Erie |
| 36% | BUFFALO | 7 | Port in New York State, US, at the eastern end of Lake Erie |
| 36% | EPHESIANS | 9 | Group in the name of a New Testament epistle |
| 36% | ERASMUS | 7 | Desiderius —, Dutch humanist whose Greek edition of the New Testament was published in 1516 |
| 36% | ERASMUS | 7 | Desiderius —, Dutch humanist who published the first Greek edition of the New Testament in 1516 |
| 34% | GOSPEL | 6 | Teaching in the New Testament |
| 34% | HORNS | 5 | Pair rendered at the top of the J in the New Jersey Devils logo |
| 34% | NEWCASTLE | 9 | Harbour city in New South Wales, Australia at the mouth of the Hunter River |
| 34% | AMEN | 4 | Last word in the New Testament |
| 34% | LUKE | 4 | Third Gospel in the New Testament |
| 34% | MAGI | 4 | Traveling trio in the New Testament |
| 34% | LUKE | 4 | Longest book in the New Testament |
| 34% | EPISTLES | 8 | Apostolic messages in the New Testament |
| 34% | TENTH | 5 | Ephesians' place in the New Testament |
| 34% | EDEN | 4 | Garden of —, Old Testament location in which Adam and Eve were placed at the Creation |
| 33% | ETERNAL | 7 | ___ Flame Falls, site of ever-burning fire at the base of the waterfall in New York |