| 100% | SPINNINGWHEEL | 13 | Rotarian's favorite song of 1969? |
| 58% | THETURNINGPOINT | 15 | Rotarian's favorite movie of 1977? |
| 54% | MOTHERPOPCORN | 13 | Edible James Brown song of 1969 |
| 48% | THISMAGICMOMENT | 15 | Favorite 60's song of 36-Across? |
| 46% | CIS | 3 | Beginning of Cookie Monster's favorite song |
| 44% | OCTOPUSSGARDEN | 14 | 1969 song recorded by 19-Across, and title of 41-Across's 2014 picture book: 2 wds. |
| 43% | KSERASERA | 9 | Fatalist's favorite song? |
| 43% | KATY | 4 | S-s-s-subject of a 1918 hit song |
| 43% | ONCEINLOVEWITHAMY | 17 | Joey Buttafuoco's favorite song |
| 43% | FURRYTHOUGHTOFYOU | 17 | "The ___" (groundhog's favorite song?) |
| 43% | LABAMBA | 7 | Mr. X's favorite song? |
| 42% | HOMEONTHERANGE | 14 | Official state song of Kansas (a favorite of deer and antelopes, for sure) |
| 41% | MITTENS | 7 | Items of apparel in the song "My Favorite Things" |
| 39% | FIRST | 5 | "___ of May," 1969 song by the Bee Gees whose title means "foremost" |
| 39% | ROCKBALLAD | 10 | Comic Chris' favorite type of song? |
| 39% | PAPERBACKWRITER | 15 | Author's favorite Beatles song? |
| 39% | WHENIMSIXTYFOUR | 15 | Sexagenarian's favorite Beatles song? |
| 39% | JUNGLEBELLS | 11 | Tarzan's favorite Christmas song? |
| 39% | AMORE | 5 | “That’s ___” (hit song of 1953) |
| 39% | SUGAR | 5 | "___ Mountain," 1969 song by Neil Young from one of his live albums |
| 38% | ADELINE | 7 | Campaign theme song of JFK's grandad: "Sweet __" |
| 38% | HERECOMESTHESUN | 15 | Early riser's favorite Beatles song? |
| 38% | SHESLEAVINGHOME | 15 | Empty nester's favorite Beatles song? |
| 38% | YELLOWSUBMARINE | 15 | Navy captain's favorite Beatles song? |
| 38% | EJOCOCKER | 9 | Singer on day three of 1969's Woodstock |
| 38% | ALANBATES | 9 | Co-star of 1969's "Women in Love" |
| 38% | ERICCARLE | 9 | Author of 1969's The Very Hungry Caterpillar |
| 38% | COMETOGETHER | 12 | 1969 #1 Beatles song that was subject of a Chuck Berry plagiarism lawsuit: 2 wds. |
| 38% | TWO | 3 | "___ of Us," VH1 drama which was named after The Beatles song released in 1969 |
| 38% | HELLO | 5 | Adele's song of greeting? |