| 100% | ELWORTHY | 8 | S —, South Africa cricketer whose 1998 Test debut was against England at Nottingham |
| 72% | TAIT | 4 | S W —, Australia cricketer whose 2005 Test debut was against England at Nottingham |
| 66% | ELWORTHY | 8 | S —, South Africa cricketer; 1998 Test debutant against England at Nottingham |
| 60% | ELWORTHY | 8 | S —, South Africa cricketer; 1998 Test debutant against England in Nottingham |
| 55% | UDAL | 4 | S D —, cricketer whose 2005 England Test debut was against Pakistan at Multan |
| 52% | MARKS | 5 | V J —, England cricketer whose 1982 Test debut was against Pakistan at Leeds |
| 51% | ROOPE | 5 | G R J —, England cricketer whose 1973 Test debut was against India at Kanpur |
| 50% | LAKMAL | 6 | R A S —, Sri Lanka cricketer whose 2010 Test debut was against West Indies at Colombo |
| 47% | CONNORS | 7 | Mark —, Australia rugby union player whose 1999 Test debut was against South Africa at Brisbane |
| 47% | HEGG | 4 | W K —, wicketkeeper whose 1998 England Test debut was against Australia at Melbourne |
| 46% | REEVE | 5 | D A —, cricketer whose 1992 England Test debut was against New Zealand at Christchurch |
| 46% | ABENDANON | 9 | Nick —, rugby union fullback whose 2007 England Test debut was against South Africa |
| 46% | SHAHZAD | 7 | A ---, cricketer whose 2010 England Test debut was against Bangladesh at Old Trafford |
| 45% | RHODES | 6 | J N —, South Africa Test cricketer who hit 117 against England at Lord's in 1998 |
| 41% | PERMAUL | 7 | V —, cricketer whose 2012 West Indies Test debut was against Bangladesh at Mirpur |
| 40% | MAY | 3 | P B H —, cricketer who hit 138 against South Africa on his 1951 England Test debut at Leeds |
| 40% | POLLOCK | 7 | S M —, South Africa Test cricketer who took 6-78 against Pakistan at Faisalabad in 2003 |
| 39% | GOUGH | 5 | D —, England Test cricketer who took 6-42 against South Africa at Leeds in 1998 |
| 39% | YARDY | 5 | M H —, England cricketer whose ODI debut was against Pakistan at Trent Bridge in 2006 |
| 38% | RABADA | 6 | K —, South Africa cricketer who took 6-16 on his 2015 ODI debut against Bangladesh at Mirpur |
| 37% | KLUSENER | 8 | L —, South Africa Test cricketer who made 174 against England in Port Elizabeth in 1999 |
| 37% | WESSELS | 7 | K C —, South Africa Test cricketer who hit 118 against India at Durban in 1992 |
| 37% | BARLOW | 6 | E J —, South Africa Test cricketer who hit 201 against Australia at Adelaide in 1964 |
| 37% | TAIT | 4 | S W —, 2005 Australia Test cricket debutant against England at Nottingham |
| 37% | NTINI | 5 | Makhaya —, South Africa Test cricketer who took 6-59 against Pakistan at Port Elizabeth in 2007 |
| 37% | NEL | 3 | A —, South Africa Test cricketer who took 6-32 against West Indies at Bridgetown in 2005 |
| 37% | STEYN | 5 | D W —, South Africa Test cricketer who took 7-51 against India at Nagpur in 2010 |
| 37% | NTINI | 5 | M —, South Africa Test cricketer who took 6-59 against Pakistan at Port Elizabeth in 2007 |