| 100% | BROAD | 5 | S C J —, England Test cricketer who took 5-85 against West Indies in Kingston in 2009 |
| 73% | SWANN | 5 | G P —, England Test cricketer who took 5-57 against West Indies in St John's, Antigua, in 2009 |
| 71% | PATEL | 5 | J S —, New Zealand Test cricketer who took 5-110 against West Indies in Napier in 2008 |
| 69% | TRUEMAN | 7 | F S —, England Test cricketer who took 5-35 against West Indies at Port-of-Spain in 1960 |
| 66% | PRINGLE | 7 | D R —, England Test cricketer who took 5-95 against West Indies in Leeds in 1988 |
| 66% | ANDERSON | 8 | J M —, England Test cricketer who took 7-42 against West Indies at Lord’s in 2017 |
| 64% | HARMISON | 8 | S J —, England Test cricketer who took 5-43 against Australia at Lord’s in 2005 |
| 62% | VAAS | 4 | W P U J C —, Sri Lanka Test cricketer who took 6-22 against West Indies in Kandy in 2005 |
| 61% | FLINTOFF | 8 | A —, England Test cricketer who took 5-92 against Australia at Lord's in 2009 |
| 61% | VAAS | 4 | W P U J C —, Sri Lanka Test cricketer who took 6-22 against West Indies at Kandy in 2005 |
| 61% | LOADER | 6 | P J —, England Test cricketer who took a hat-trick against West Indies in Leeds in 1957 |
| 59% | CORK | 4 | D G —, England Test cricketer who took 7-43 against West Indies at Lord's in 1995 |
| 59% | BOPARA | 6 | R S —, England Test cricketer who hit 104 against West Indies in Bridgetown in 2009 |
| 59% | MILLER | 6 | K R —, Australia Test cricketer who took 5-26 against West Indies in Sydney in 1952 |
| 58% | TUDOR | 5 | A J —, England Test cricketer who took 5-44 against Australia at Nottingham in 2001 |
| 57% | GREIG | 5 | A W —, England Test cricketer who took 8-86 against West Indies in Port of Spain in 1974 |
| 57% | GARNER | 6 | J —, West Indies Test cricketer who took 5-56 against Australia in Adelaide in 1982 |
| 57% | RAMADHIN | 8 | S —, West Indies Test cricketer who took 7-49 against England at Birmingham in 1957 |
| 57% | SMALL | 5 | G C —, England Test cricketer who took 5-48 against Australia in Melbourne in 1986 |
| 57% | SMALL | 5 | G C —, England Test cricketer who took 5-48 against Australia at Melbourne in 1986 |
| 57% | PANESAR | 7 | M S —, England Test cricketer who took 5-72 against Pakistan at Manchester in 2006 |
| 56% | MADANLAL | 8 | S —, India Test cricketer who took 5-23 against England at Mumbai in 1981 |
| 56% | AMBROSE | 7 | C E L —, West Indies Test cricketer who took 8-45 against England in Bridgetown in 1990 |
| 56% | AMBROSE | 7 | C E L —, West Indies Test cricketer who took 8-45 against England at Bridgetown in 1990 |
| 56% | GILES | 5 | A F —, England cricketer who took 5-57 against West Indies at Birmingham in 2004 |
| 56% | WALSH | 5 | C A —, West Indies Test cricketer who took 5-54 against India in 1987 in Delhi and Mumbai |
| 56% | PRIOR | 5 | M J —, England Test cricketer who hit 126 not out against West Indies at Lord's in 2007 |
| 56% | GREIG | 5 | A W —, England Test cricketer who took 8-86 against West Indies at Port of Spain in 1974 |
| 56% | MALCOLM | 7 | D E —, England Test cricketer who took 6-77 against West Indies at Port-of-Spain in 1990 |
| 56% | DRAKES | 6 | V C —, West Indies Test cricketer who took 5-93 against Australia at Georgetown in 2003 |