| 100% | HALO | 4 | Saintly glow that Beyoncé wrote a song about |
| 52% | RIVER | 5 | Joni Mitchell song about heartbreak that's popular around the holidays but wasn't originally written as a Christmas song |
| 51% | FROSTY | 6 | "___ the Snowman," holiday tune about a magical snowman that wasn't originally written as a Christmas song |
| 51% | HALO | 4 | Beyoncé song with a title that describes a saintly glow |
| 46% | ICARE | 5 | Beyonce song about someone still invested in a relationship |
| 46% | MRLEE | 5 | 1957 Bobbettes song written about a schoolteacher |
| 45% | PLAGUE | 6 | Disease that Daniel Defoe wrote a novel about |
| 45% | SANDMAN | 7 | "Enter ___," 1991 Metallica song about a folklore figure that puts you to sleep |
| 44% | COMPOSE | 7 | Write a song |
| 44% | DEMONLEMON | 10 | Dud of a car that Stephen King might write about? |
| 44% | PEGOMYHEART | 11 | Classic song about an Irish lass that was a #1 hit in 1913 and 1947 |
| 43% | BELLS | 5 | "Jingle ___," popular holiday song about sleigh rides that was originally written for Thanksgiving and not Christmas |
| 43% | TAX | 3 | “Cheese ___” (viral TikTok song about the fee that a dog demands when its owner is cooking) |
| 42% | EAGLES | 6 | Band that wrote song about lodging in California |
| 42% | DIGITAL | 7 | "___ Fortress," thriller written by Dan Brown about a supercomputer that cracks cryptic codes |
| 42% | HEROES | 6 | David Bowie song about two lovers divided by the Berlin Wall that was used in a Microsoft commercial |
| 42% | ONEFINEDAY | 10 | 1980 Carole King song about a love-to-be that was recorded earlier by the Chiffons: 3 wds. |
| 41% | ADIDAS | 6 | Athletic shoe brand that Run-D.M.C. rapped about in a 1986 song |
| 41% | AVEMARIA | 8 | Beyoncé song that samples a Schubert composition |
| 41% | SINGLE | 6 | "___ Ladies (Put a Ring on It)," 2008 song by Beyonce that won three Grammy Awards |
| 41% | TELEPHONE | 9 | 2010 song from "The Fame Monster" that was a collab between Lady Gaga and Beyonce |
| 41% | PEARL | 5 | "Mama's ___," 1970 song by the Jackson 5 that is about a mama's girl |
| 41% | SHE | 3 | "___ Works Hard for the Money," song by Donna Summer that is about a hardworking woman |
| 41% | JET | 3 | "Leaving on a ___ Plane," John Denver song that talks about the bittersweet feeling of departure |
| 40% | ISAWTHELIGHT | 12 | Biopic about 18-Across, and the title of a classic gospel song he wrote: 4 wds. |
| 40% | BASS | 4 | "All About That ___," 2014 song by Meghan Trainor with a low-pitched instrument in its title |
| 40% | AVE | 3 | "___ Maria," hymn dedicated to the Virgin Mary that wasn't originally written as a Christmas song |
| 40% | MOONOVERMIAMI | 13 | Song about a resort city |
| 39% | TIME | 4 | "Until the End of ___," song by Justin Timberlake that was re-recorded as a duet with Beyonce |