| 100% | LIST | 4 | Santa checks his twice, in song |
| 49% | LIST | 4 | Something that's checked twice, in a Christmas song |
| 48% | LIST | 4 | Twice-checked item in a Christmas song |
| 47% | TWICE | 5 | How often Santa checks his list |
| 47% | LIST | 4 | Santa checks it twice |
| 45% | LIST | 4 | What Santa checks twice |
| 44% | SACKS | 5 | Santa carries his toys in them |
| 43% | SERA | 4 | Word twice in a Doris Day song |
| 41% | SERA | 4 | Word appearing twice in a Doris Day song title |
| 40% | LIST | 4 | What Santa makes and checks twice |
| 40% | LIST | 4 | Something Santa makes (and checks twice) |
| 40% | WORKSHOP | 8 | Building Santa makes his toys in |
| 40% | SACK | 4 | What Santa carries his toys in |
| 40% | LIST | 4 | What Santa checks twice to see who's naughty and nice |
| 40% | LIST | 4 | What Santa's making (and checking twice) |
| 39% | HESA | 4 | "___ Devil in His Own Home Town" (classic song) |
| 39% | CANDY | 5 | 50 cent's shop in his famous song |
| 39% | SERA | 4 | It comes twice after "que" in a song |
| 39% | PITBULL | 7 | Latin artist who says 305 in his songs |
| 38% | SERA | 4 | Word sung twice after "Que" in a classic song |
| 38% | TOKER | 5 | Steve Miller at midnight, in one of his songs |
| 38% | IRA | 3 | Judy sings his songs in "A Star Is Born" |
| 37% | SEXY | 4 | What Justin Timberlake's bringing back in his popular song |
| 37% | TALK | 4 | What Chet Faker says "Is Cheap," in his eponymous song |
| 37% | CLAPTONOFTHUNDER | 16 | Rocker known for the loud crashing noises in his songs? |
| 37% | THAT | 4 | "They know ___ Santa's on his way" ("The Christmas Song" lyric) |
| 36% | DESIREE | 7 | "Girl almost twice my age" in a 1977 Neil Diamond song |
| 36% | LONGI | 5 | It's heard twice in "hi-fi" |
| 36% | EVERETT | 7 | Betty who sang "The Shoop Shoop Song (It's in His Kiss)" |
| 36% | MOMMY | 5 | Who Jimmy Boyd saw Santa Claus kissing in a 1952 Christmas song? |