| 100% | NOEXIT | 6 | Sartre play set in hell |
| 55% | OURTOWN | 7 | Play set in Grover's Corners |
| 55% | BUSSTOP | 7 | Play set in a Kansas diner |
| 55% | OTHELLO | 7 | Play set in Venice and Cyprus |
| 54% | DIVECOMEDY | 10 | Play set in a low-class bar? |
| 54% | BOUNCERS | 8 | Play set in a 1980s Belfast nightclub |
| 54% | HAMLET | 6 | Shakespeare play set in Denmark |
| 54% | OTHELLO | 7 | Shakespeare play set in Venice |
| 54% | CYMBELINE | 9 | Shakespeare play set in uk |
| 53% | OURTOWN | 7 | Play set in Grover’s Corners, New Hampshire |
| 53% | MURDERONTHENILE | 15 | Agatha Christie play set in Egypt |
| 52% | OTHELLO | 7 | Play set mostly in Cyprus |
| 51% | OURTOWN | 7 | Pulitzer-winning play set in Grover's Corners |
| 51% | ARCADIA | 7 | 1993 Tom Stoppard play set in multiple times |
| 50% | INFERNO | 7 | Part of Dante's "Divine Comedy" set in hell |
| 50% | SHEAR | 5 | “___ Madness,” Paul Pörtner play set in a hair salon |
| 50% | OURTOWN | 7 | ... bad / Thornton Wilder play set in Grover's Corners |
| 50% | STEELMAGNOLIAS | 14 | Play set entirely in a beauty parlor |
| 49% | PHEDRE | 6 | 5-act French play set in the court of Troezen |
| 49% | TRU | 3 | 1989 Broadway play set in a writer's Manhattan apartment |
| 49% | TRU | 3 | 1989 Broadway play set in a writer's New York apartment |
| 49% | OLEANNA | 7 | Two-character David Mamet play set in a professor’s office |
| 47% | RUR | 3 | Classic 1921 play set partly in a factory |
| 46% | AVIEWFROM | 9 | With 23-Down, Arthur Miller play set in a Brooklyn waterfront neighborhood: 3 wds. |
| 46% | MISSJULIE | 9 | Strindberg play set on a count's estate in Sweden |
| 44% | DRIVE | 5 | Set of offensive plays, in football |
| 44% | BIMINISERIES | 12 | Set of championship games played in part of the Bahamas? |
| 44% | ASSIST | 6 | Play or touch that sets up a goal in soccer |
| 42% | AUDRA | 5 | McDonald set to play Gypsy Rose Lee in fall 2024 |
| 41% | EZRA | 4 | ___ Miller, who is set to play The Flash in "Justice League" |