| 100% | TALKLIKEAPIRATE | 15 | Say "Arrr" and "Shiver me timbers" |
| 53% | PIRATE | 6 | Sailor who might say "Shiver me timbers!" |
| 52% | PAIR | 4 | You and me, say |
| 52% | XXXXXXXXXX | 10 | You and me, say |
| 51% | ENDSIT | 6 | Says "You and I are done," e.g. |
| 50% | OUR | 3 | Belonging to you and me, say |
| 50% | WHATISAID | 9 | I Said __, social commentary pod by FK and Jollz |
| 49% | HELLO | 5 | "You say goodbye, and I say ___" |
| 49% | GOSH | 4 | "Shiver me timbers," to a non-pirate |
| 49% | IVE | 3 | "___ said it before and I'll say it again ..." |
| 49% | TEAPOT | 6 | I'm a little __, short and stout, said the rhyme |
| 46% | KAISERS | 7 | Franz I and Ferdinand I, say |
| 46% | ASSUME | 6 | Make an ass out of u and me, as they say |
| 46% | BEFORE | 6 | "I've said it ___ and I'll say it again . . ." |
| 46% | YSL | 3 | Designer who said, "Chanel freed women, and I empowered them.": Abbr. |
| 46% | ETCETERA | 8 | In The King and I, the king says this three times |
| 45% | RON | 3 | Swanson who said "Give me all the bacon and eggs you have" |
| 44% | UNTO | 4 | "And so I say ___ you ..." |
| 44% | EYRE | 4 | Literary character who says, "I am no bird; and no net ensnares me" |
| 44% | EYRE | 4 | Fictional Jane who said "I am no bird; and no net ensnares me" |
| 44% | BERLE | 5 | TV great who said "I live to laugh, and I laugh to live" |
| 44% | ONO | 3 | About whom Lennon said, “She’s the teacher and I’m the pupil” |
| 44% | DID | 3 | "They said 'Babe, you gotta fake it till you make it' and I ___" |
| 43% | IVEGOTYOURNUMBER | 16 | "You're not fooling me!," or what 18-, 28-, and 43-Across might say? |
| 43% | ADAM | 4 | Bible character who says "She gave me of the tree, and I did eat" |
| 43% | ARDEN | 5 | Who said "There's only one Elizabeth like me, and that's the queen" |
| 43% | EER | 3 | "Give my regards to old Broadway / And say that I'll be there ___ long" |
| 43% | SHIVER | 6 | "___ me timbers!" |
| 42% | HEGEL | 5 | He purportedly said "Only one man ever understood me, and he didn't understand me" |
| 42% | DONNE | 5 | “I am two fools, I know, / For loving, and for saying so / In whining Poetry” writer |