| 100% | STAFFA | 6 | Scottish island that's home to Fingal's Cave |
| 73% | STAFFA | 6 | Scottish island home to Fingal's Cave |
| 63% | CRETE | 5 | Greek island that is home to the Ideon Cave |
| 59% | OAHU | 4 | Island that's home to Honolulu |
| 58% | OAHU | 4 | Island that's home to Pearl Harbor |
| 58% | OAHU | 4 | Island that's home to Waikiki Beach |
| 58% | NESS | 4 | Scottish loch that's home to a "monster" |
| 58% | OAHU | 4 | Island that's home to a state capital |
| 57% | OAHU | 4 | Hawaiian island that's home to Waikiki |
| 57% | OAHU | 4 | Hawaiian island that's home to Honolulu |
| 57% | PANAY | 5 | Philippine island that's home to Iloilo |
| 57% | KOMODO | 6 | Island that's home to the world's largest lizard |
| 57% | OAHU | 4 | Island that's home to Kailua Bay and Diamond Head |
| 56% | OAHU | 4 | Hawaiian island that's home to Diamond Head |
| 56% | OAHU | 4 | Hawaiian island that's home to Pearl Harbor |
| 56% | HONSHU | 6 | Island that's home to over 80% of Japan's population |
| 56% | OAHU | 4 | Island that’s home to Iolani Palace |
| 55% | BORNEO | 6 | Island that's home to most of the world's wild orangutans |
| 55% | OAHU | 4 | Hawaiian island that's home to about a million people |
| 55% | PALAU | 5 | Island nation that's home to Rock Islands |
| 55% | OAHU | 4 | Hawaiian island that's home to the Prince Lot Hula Festival |
| 54% | GUAM | 4 | Island that’s home to Andersen Air Force Base |
| 54% | ERIE | 4 | Lake that's home to Kelleys Island |
| 54% | BASRA | 5 | Arabian port that's home to Sinbad Island |
| 54% | ERIE | 4 | Lake that's home to South Bass Island |
| 54% | ERIE | 4 | Great Lake that's home to Pelee Island |
| 54% | MALTA | 5 | Island country that’s home to pastizzi pastries |
| 54% | KEY | 3 | ___ West, island in Florida that is home to the Harry S. Truman Little White House |
| 54% | KAUAI | 5 | Island that's home to Waimea Canyon, a.k.a. the Grand Canyon of Hawaii |
| 53% | OAHU | 4 | Hawaiian island that's home to the only royal palace in the US |