| 100% | GOMEZ | 5 | Selena ___, "Same Old Love" singer who hosted an episode of 16a. in 2022 |
| 65% | BENEDICT | 8 | ___ Cumberbatch, "Doctor Strange" actor who hosted an episode of 16a. in 2022 |
| 41% | WILL | 4 | ___ Forte, "Nebraska" actor who hosted S47 of 16a. in 2022 |
| 40% | LYONNE | 6 | Natasha ___, "Russian Doll" actress who hosted S47 of 16a. in 2022 |
| 40% | DAFOE | 5 | Willem ___, "American Psycho" actor who hosted S47 of 16a. in 2022 |
| 36% | GOMEZ | 5 | “Same Old Love” singer Selena |
| 36% | GOMEZ | 5 | "Same Old Love" singer Selena ___ |
| 35% | BRETMICHAELS | 12 | Poison singer who starred in "Rock of Love": 2 wds. |
| 35% | KAL | 3 | Actor Penn who hosted eight episodes of "The Daily Show" in 2023 |
| 34% | NICK | 4 | ___ Jonas, "Sucker" singer who participated in an episode of "Running Wild with Bear Grylls" |
| 34% | PINK | 4 | Singer who stylizes her name with an exclamation mark in place of the second letter |
| 34% | TREBEK | 6 | Host who phrased his questions in the form of an answer |
| 34% | GREGORIANCHANTEUSE | 18 | Cabaret singer in the style of an old pope? |
| 34% | LIZZO | 5 | "Truth Hurts" singer who won an Emmy in 2022 |
| 34% | ERYKAHBADU | 10 | "Tyrone" singer who competed against Jill Scott in a 2020 episode of "Verzuz": 2 wds. |
| 33% | JON | 3 | ___ Batiste, "We Are" singer who won the Grammy Award for Album of the Year in 2022 |
| 33% | JACKSON | 7 | Singer who appeared in a Pepsi commercial featuring an altered version of his song "Billie Jean" in 1984, Michael ___ |
| 33% | GOMEZ | 5 | Selena of "Same Old Love" |
| 32% | NICKJONAS | 9 | "Jealous" pop singer who both hosted and was the musical act in a 2021 "SNL" episode: 2 wds. |
| 32% | RYE | 3 | “The ___” (“Seinfeld” episode in which Jerry steals a loaf of bread from an old woman) |
| 31% | LOIS | 4 | Smith who, in 2021, at the age of ninety, became the oldest winner of an acting Tony |
| 31% | MARIAHCAREY | 11 | "Vision of Love" singer who won the Best New Artist Grammy in 1991: 2 wds. |
| 31% | GUTHRIE | 7 | Arlo ___, singer of "Alice's Restaurant" who starred in a movie of the same name based on Thanksgiving |
| 30% | CITY | 4 | "___ of Angels," 1998 American fantasy film starring Nicolas Cage as an angel who falls in love with a mortal woman |
| 30% | MEATLOAF | 8 | The Bat Out of Hell singer who died in 2022 |
| 30% | EROS | 4 | Love god who's an anagram of "rose" |
| 30% | BRET | 4 | Michaels who hosted Rock of Love |
| 30% | MEGANTHEE | 9 | With 46-Across, "Savage" rapper who both hosted and was the musical act in a 2022 "SNL" episode: 2 wds. |
| 30% | CHER | 4 | Singer who announced an upcoming album of ABBA covers |
| 29% | ADELE | 5 | Singer who was awarded an M.B.E. in 2013 |