| 100% | SIGHT | 5 | Sense that many cave-dwelling animals lack |
| 50% | BAT | 3 | Cave-dwelling animal that flies |
| 49% | BLIND | 5 | Like many animals that live deep in caves |
| 44% | SMELL | 5 | Sense that dolphins lack |
| 40% | TAIL | 4 | Animal part that humans lack |
| 39% | BAT | 3 | Animal that flies in a cave |
| 39% | BAT | 3 | Animal that flies around a cave |
| 39% | BATS | 4 | Animals that hang out in caves |
| 39% | CHIN | 4 | Facial feature that many characters on "The Simpsons" lack |
| 38% | CATS | 4 | Animals that fill up many Instagram feeds |
| 38% | BAT | 3 | Animal that might fly around a cave |
| 38% | BATS | 4 | Animals that hang upside-down in caves |
| 38% | DEER | 4 | Animal in many cave paintings |
| 38% | BATS | 4 | Cave-dwelling animals |
| 38% | BAT | 3 | Animal that hangs upside-down in a cave |
| 38% | RAT | 3 | Animal in "Ratatouille," in more than one sense |
| 38% | TAIL | 4 | Common animal feature that humans lack |
| 37% | NOCTURNAL | 9 | Animals that are more active at night are this |
| 37% | BAT | 3 | Flying animal that lives in a cave |
| 36% | AESOP | 5 | Creator of many fables that feature talking animals |
| 36% | CLAM | 4 | Animal that spends most of its life buried in the sand |
| 35% | BAT | 3 | Black animal that might hang from a cave ceiling |
| 35% | FISH | 4 | Animal group that's been around for more than 500 million years |
| 35% | COW | 3 | Animal that's spotted on a farm, in more ways than one |
| 35% | APE | 3 | Type of animal that's most closely related to humans |
| 34% | NEST | 4 | Animal dwelling that might be built inside a letter of a store sign |
| 34% | YAKS | 4 | Hairy Tibetan animals that can weigh more than 2,000 pounds |
| 34% | TROLL | 5 | Supernatural creature in Scandinavian folklore that dwell in caves and mountains |
| 34% | MOOSE | 5 | Antlered animal that can reach more than seven feet in height |