| 100% | TINSTAR | 7 | Sheriff's badge in the Old West |
| 60% | CATTLE | 6 | They were driven in the Old West |
| 59% | EARP | 4 | Holliday-party member in the Old West? |
| 59% | ETTA | 4 | Place in the Old West |
| 59% | PARD | 4 | Crony, in the old West |
| 59% | STAGE | 5 | Transportation in the Old West |
| 58% | EARP | 4 | Family name in the Old West |
| 58% | PONYEXPRESS | 11 | It delivered in the Old West |
| 58% | SALOONS | 7 | Watering holes in the Old West |
| 58% | DERRINGERPISTOL | 15 | Popular shooter in the Old West |
| 58% | FORTYNINER | 10 | 36-Across, in the Old West |
| 57% | TRADINGPOST | 11 | Place to do business in the Old West |
| 57% | FRONTIERSTANZAQUEST | 19 | Search for poetry in the Old West? [Nissan] |
| 57% | EARP | 4 | One of three brothers in the Old West |
| 57% | CASSIDY | 7 | Butch __, notorious bank robber in the Old West |
| 57% | DUEL | 4 | Two-person shoot-out in the Old West |
| 55% | KUNGFU | 6 | 1970s TV show with a Shaolin monk in the Old West |
| 54% | LAWMEN | 6 | Guys wearing badges in the Wild West |
| 53% | DODGECITY | 9 | Wild frontier town of the Old West in Kansas |
| 53% | JOHNNYDEPP | 10 | Actor who voiced Rango, a heroic green chameleon in the Old West: 2 wds. |
| 52% | DEADCHEAT | 9 | Poker player in the Old West after being caught with a card up his sleeve? |
| 51% | EARP | 4 | The Old West’s Wyatt |
| 48% | FRONTIERJUSTICE | 15 | Law of the jungle, in the Old West |
| 48% | AARON | 5 | In the Old Testament, he was Moses's brother |
| 48% | POSSE | 5 | Old West sheriff's group |
| 47% | CALEB | 5 | Joshua's companion, in the Old Testament |
| 47% | ETHER | 5 | Surgeon's supply in the old days |
| 47% | YET | 3 | "There's life in the old dog ___!" |
| 47% | ELI | 3 | Samuel's teacher, in the Old Testament |
| 47% | ABEL | 4 | Cain's brother, in the Old Testament |