| 100% | EVENER | 6 | Shot that sends a game into overtime |
| 83% | EVENER | 6 | Goal that sends a game into overtime |
| 83% | TIE | 3 | Situation that sends a game into overtime |
| 49% | TIE | 3 | Cause of a game going into overtime |
| 47% | TIED | 4 | Like a game headed into overtime |
| 44% | NAILBITERS | 10 | Games that go into overtime |
| 43% | THRILLERS | 9 | Games that go into overtime, say |
| 42% | NAILBITER | 9 | Game that goes into overtime, e.g. |
| 40% | TIED | 4 | Like games that head into overtime |
| 40% | TIED | 4 | Like games that go into overtime |
| 39% | FRIENDSTER | 10 | Social networking site of the '00s that later evolved into a social gaming site |
| 38% | TIEITUP | 7 | Force a game into extra innings, say |
| 37% | GOTOJAIL | 8 | Monopoly command that sends a player to prison |
| 37% | PAN | 3 | Shot that moves across a landscape |
| 37% | TENSE | 5 | Like a game overtime |
| 37% | AXE | 3 | Tool that sends a shiver down the tree bark |
| 37% | TEXT | 4 | Send a message that may include emojis |
| 36% | THREE | 5 | Shot that Steph Curry makes a lot of |
| 36% | LOB | 3 | Shot that goes high above a tennis court |
| 36% | TIED | 4 | Like a game headed to overtime |
| 36% | TIED | 4 | Like a game heading to overtime |
| 36% | TIED | 4 | Like a game headed for overtime |
| 36% | ALAI | 4 | Half a game name that rhymes |
| 36% | ELATES | 6 | Sends into a swoon |
| 36% | ENRAPTURE | 9 | Send into a swoon |
| 36% | ENRAGE | 6 | Send into a fury |
| 35% | LOB | 3 | Shot that goes over a tennis player's head |
| 35% | TIE | 3 | Like a score that leads to overtime |
| 35% | TIED | 4 | Like a game heading into extra innings |
| 35% | TIE | 3 | Result of a game that nobody wins |