| 100% | STOMP | 5 | Show still running at New York's Orpheum Theater after 25 years |
| 32% | NEIL | 4 | With 44-Down, only playwright to have a New York City theater named after him while still alive |
| 29% | OPERA | 5 | Offering at New York's Lincoln Center |
| 29% | MET | 3 | Athlete at New York's Citi Field |
| 28% | LUNT | 4 | New York's ___-Fontanne Theater |
| 28% | RCABUILDING | 11 | Onetime name at New York's Rockefeller Center |
| 28% | OBIE | 4 | Award presented at New York's Webster Hall |
| 28% | MET | 3 | Baseball player at New York's Citi Field |
| 28% | READE | 5 | Walter who has a New York movie theater named after him |
| 28% | NBC | 3 | TV network headquartered at New York's Rockefeller Center |
| 28% | ERIE | 4 | Canal that starts at New York's Hudson River |
| 27% | MELOTT | 6 | He led the New York Giants in home runs for 18 consecutive years |
| 27% | RINKS | 5 | Winter sights at New York's Rockefeller Center and Bryant Park |
| 27% | MACYS | 5 | Flagship store at New York City's Herald Square |
| 27% | GALA | 4 | Affair at New York City's Met, for one |
| 27% | SNL | 3 | New York sketch-comedy show that premièred in 1975 (and is still on the air), briefly |
| 27% | BROADWAY | 8 | New York City's theater capital |
| 26% | PEASALAD | 8 | Side dish popular at New Year's |
| 26% | CONFETTI | 8 | New Year's Eve shower |
| 25% | ADAMS | 5 | New York City's mayor after de Blasio |
| 25% | WARHOL | 6 | Painter Andy whose "Orange Disaster #5" is on display at New York's Guggenheim Museum |
| 25% | FAME | 4 | 1980 musical film set at New York City's High School of Performing Arts |
| 25% | METS | 4 | New York MLB team featured in Ira Berkow's "Summers at Shea" |
| 25% | CAKE | 4 | Dessert that might get cut at New Year's parties |
| 25% | EVE | 3 | New Year's ___ (occasion with champagne at midnight) |
| 25% | PAPP | 4 | Founder of New York's Public Theater |
| 24% | MIMOSA | 6 | Champagne and orange juice concoction that you may enjoy at 4d after New Year festivities |
| 24% | OBIE | 4 | New York theater award |
| 24% | OBIES | 5 | New York theater awards |
| 24% | MACYS | 5 | Sponsor of New York City's Fourth of July fireworks show |