| 100% | CAROLS | 6 | Singing ___, once popular door-to-door Christmas tradition that is slowly disappearing |
| 47% | CAROL | 5 | Christmas song that may be sung door-to-door |
| 38% | CAROLING | 8 | Singing Christmas songs door to door |
| 35% | SILENT | 6 | "___ Night," Christmas carol that was first sung on December 24th, 1818 |
| 35% | CAROLS | 6 | Songs that are sung at Christmas time |
| 35% | OSLO | 4 | Capital that was once home to Vikings |
| 34% | NOG | 3 | Creamy egg beverage that is popular around Christmas |
| 34% | GOBI | 4 | Desert that was once home to Tarbosaurus bataar |
| 34% | FLATBUSH | 8 | Neighborhood that was once home to Ebbets Field |
| 34% | PERU | 4 | Country that was once home to the Incan Empire |
| 34% | PERU | 4 | Country that was once home to the Inca Empire |
| 34% | FLEABANE | 8 | Daisylike flower that was once believed to repel insects |
| 34% | SEAAIR | 6 | Atmosphere that was once believed to help cure tuberculosis |
| 34% | GHOST | 5 | Telling ___ stories, old spooky Christmas Eve tradition that is now closely associated with Halloween |
| 33% | MAURITIUS | 9 | Island that was once home to the extinct dodo bird |
| 33% | OREM | 4 | City that was once home to the Osmonds' TV studio |
| 33% | MAURITIUS | 9 | African nation that was once home to the dodo bird |
| 33% | IVORY | 5 | Material that was once carved to make Chinese puzzle balls |
| 33% | TULSA | 5 | Oklahoma city that was once home to "Black Wall Street" |
| 33% | IVORY | 5 | Off-white material that was once carved to make netsuke |
| 33% | EASTEND | 7 | Area of London that was once home to many dockworkers |
| 33% | TULSA | 5 | Southern city that was once home to Black Wall Street |
| 33% | NAPSTER | 7 | File-sharing application predominantly used to share audio files that was popular in the 2000s |
| 33% | PALEO | 5 | Popular diet said to consist only of foods that were available to cavemen |
| 33% | RAGU | 4 | A popular brand of marinara sauce that is rival to Prego |
| 33% | CORN | 4 | Kerneled veggie that is popped to make a popular movie snack |
| 33% | SHEA | 4 | Stadium that was once home to the Mets and the Jets |
| 33% | PERU | 4 | South American country that was once home to the Incan Empire |
| 33% | BELLS | 5 | "Jingle ___," popular holiday song about sleigh rides that was originally written for Thanksgiving and not Christmas |
| 33% | FOOT | 4 | Rabbit's ___, amulet believed to bring good luck that was once gifted to President Theodore Roosevelt |