| 100% | UTLEY | 5 | Six-time All-Star second baseman Chase ___ |
| 80% | UTLEY | 5 | Five-time All-Star second baseman Chase ___ |
| 64% | CEY | 3 | Six-time All-Star third baseman for the 1970s Dodgers |
| 64% | CEY | 3 | Six-time All-Star third baseman of the 1970s Dodgers |
| 63% | ROBERTOALOMAR | 13 | 12-time All-Star second baseman born in Puerto Rico (his brother Sandy's a six-time All-Star): 2 wds. |
| 60% | IAN | 3 | Four-time All-Star second baseman Kinsler |
| 57% | OMAR | 4 | All-Star second baseman Infante |
| 57% | CANO | 4 | All-Star second baseman Robinson |
| 57% | UTLEY | 5 | Six-time baseball All-Star Chase |
| 53% | UTLEY | 5 | Longtime M.L.B. second baseman Chase |
| 53% | CEY | 3 | Six-time All-Star Ron |
| 53% | STAUB | 5 | Six-time All-Star Rusty |
| 53% | NOMAR | 5 | Six-time All-Star Garciaparra |
| 53% | JOSE | 4 | Six-time All-Star Bautista |
| 53% | ALOU | 4 | Six-time All-Star Moises |
| 53% | JOSE | 4 | Six-time All-Star Canseco |
| 52% | SALE | 4 | Six-time All-Star pitcher Chris |
| 52% | UTLEY | 5 | American second baseman, Chase ___ |
| 50% | BENZOBRIST | 10 | Cubs second baseman who started the 2016 MLB All-Star Game: 2 wds. |
| 49% | JACKIEROBINSON | 14 | MLB second baseman and 6-time consecutive All-Star, who served in the segregated Army cavalry unit in Kansas during WWII: 2 wds. |
| 48% | PAULGOLDSCHMIDT | 15 | Six-time All-Star for the Arizona Diamondbacks (2013-18) |
| 48% | ROBINSONCANO | 12 | Seattle Mariners second baseman who won the 2017 MLB All-Star Game MVP: 2 wds. |
| 48% | ALOMAR | 6 | Six-time baseball All-Star Sandy |
| 48% | STAUB | 5 | Six-time baseball All-Star Rusty |
| 48% | AMARE | 5 | Six-time NBA All-Star Stoudemire |
| 48% | JOSE | 4 | Six-time MLB All-Star Bautista |
| 48% | ORDONEZ | 7 | Six-time MLB All-Star Magglio |
| 48% | ALOU | 4 | Six-time MLB All-Star Moisés |
| 48% | PAU | 3 | Six-time NBA All-Star Gasol |
| 48% | PAU | 3 | Six-time NBA All-Star __ Gasol |