| 100% | AMOUNTS | 7 | Six of one and half a dozen of the other, say? |
| 75% | EQUAL | 5 | Six of one, half a dozen of the other |
| 64% | SIX | 3 | "___ of one, half a dozen of the other" |
| 58% | ONE | 3 | "Six of ___, half a dozen of the other" |
| 57% | DOZEN | 5 | "Six of one, half a ___ of the other" |
| 56% | SIXOFONE | 8 | __ and half-a-dozen of the other |
| 50% | ALAN | 4 | One of the "Two and a Half Men" |
| 50% | ALAN | 4 | One of the men on "Two and a Half Men" |
| 49% | BFF | 3 | One with the other half of a broken heart necklace, perhaps (Abbr.) |
| 48% | EXERCISEYOURRIGHT | 17 | Vote, say, and a clue to one side of the asterisked answers |
| 47% | GNOME | 5 | One of a species of legendary creatures said to live in the depths of the earth and guard buried treasure |
| 46% | TELEMARK | 8 | In skiing, a turn in which one ski is placed far forward of the other and turned gradually inwards |
| 45% | SSW | 3 | One of the half winds on a compass rose that was named "Ostro-Libeccio" in the 14th and 15th centuries |
| 43% | KENNYLOGGINS | 12 | "We Are the World" singer who was half of a famous duo (oh, and one more thing...) |
| 43% | SOBELOW | 7 | The other half of the saying |
| 43% | OFONE | 5 | "Six ___ and half a dozen..." |
| 43% | WANNABET | 8 | "Care to wager?" ... and a question answered, one way or the other, by the first words of the answers to starred clues |
| 43% | LIFELIFELIFELIFE | 16 | The other half of a 55-Across |
| 43% | OSCAR | 5 | (With 13-Across) "My wallpaper and I are fighting a duel to the death. One or the other of us has to go" |
| 42% | WIDTH | 5 | Measurement from one side of a pool to the other |
| 42% | IDIOM | 5 | "In one ear and out the other," say |
| 42% | ARUM | 4 | Species of the plant alternately known as snakeshead, cuckoo pint, lords-and-ladies, jack in the pulpit and more than a dozen other names |
| 42% | RULE | 4 | One of the pre-set regulations of a particular sport, say |
| 42% | MATE | 4 | One of a pair of gloves, to the other |
| 42% | EMMA | 4 | Title heroine who says "One half of the world cannot understand the pleasures of the other" |
| 42% | SIX | 3 | Half of a dozen or the next number in a New Year's countdown |
| 42% | POLESAPART | 10 | In complete opposition ... and a feature of the four other longest answers |
| 41% | ALADDIN | 7 | One of the stories of A Thousand And One Nights |
| 41% | SARAH | 5 | Author of novels Getting Even and The Other Half |