| 100% | PAPA | 4 | Smurf who wears a red hat |
| 68% | STAN | 4 | "South Park" kid who wears a blue and red hat |
| 61% | MARIO | 5 | Plumber who wears a red cap |
| 60% | HELLOKITTY | 10 | Toon who wears a red hair bow |
| 60% | IRONMAN | 7 | Avenger who wears a red metal suit |
| 60% | CARMENSANDIEGO | 14 | TV show whose protagonist wears a red hat |
| 59% | SUPERMAN | 8 | Comic-book hero who wears a red cape |
| 59% | CHIPMUNK | 8 | Cartoon character Alvin who wears a red sweater |
| 58% | WALDO | 5 | Book character who wears a red-and-white-striped shirt |
| 58% | POOH | 4 | Cartoon bear who wears a red shirt and no pants |
| 57% | FROSTY | 6 | Snowman who wears a magician's hat |
| 57% | WALDO | 5 | Children's book character who wears a red and white striped shirt |
| 56% | MINNIE | 6 | Mickey Mouse's girlfriend who wears a red polka dot dress and bow |
| 55% | MAGILLA | 7 | Hanna-Barbera gorilla who wore a tiny purple hat |
| 55% | PAPA | 4 | Smurf with a red hat |
| 55% | URCHIN | 6 | "Sir" in "SpongeBob SquarePants" who wears a blue top hat |
| 55% | YOGI | 4 | Cartoon bear who wears a green necktie and porkpie hat |
| 54% | ELF | 3 | Christmas figure who wears a pointy hat |
| 53% | MARIO | 5 | Video-game character who wears overalls and a red hat |
| 53% | HOLMES | 6 | Detective Sherlock, who wore a deerstalker hat |
| 52% | ITT | 3 | "Addams Family" cousin who wears sunglasses and a hat |
| 51% | ITT | 3 | TV character who wears nothing but a bowler hat and sunglasses |
| 51% | EDITH | 5 | "Despicable Me" daughter who wears a pink hat |
| 50% | TOADETTE | 8 | Childlike character in the Super Mario games who wears a pink dress with a pink mushroom hat |
| 48% | CLOWN | 5 | Circus performer who might wear a red nose |
| 46% | PAPA | 4 | Smurf with a white beard and a red hat |
| 45% | TIE | 3 | SpongeBob wears a red one |
| 45% | NUN | 3 | Woman who wears a habit |
| 45% | KING | 4 | Man who wears a crown |
| 45% | MINNIE | 6 | Mouse who wears a bow |