| 100% | PACT | 4 | Something Faust reportedly made with the devil |
| 52% | APACT | 5 | Make ___ with the devil |
| 48% | PACT | 4 | Someone striking a deal with the Devil makes one |
| 47% | WISH | 4 | Something frequently made with the eyes shut |
| 45% | FAUST | 5 | He made a deal with the devil |
| 45% | FAUST | 5 | He made a pact with the Devil |
| 40% | TAROT | 5 | Deal with The Devil? |
| 39% | ANG | 3 | Lee who directed “Ride with the Devil” |
| 39% | LEE | 3 | Ang ___ who directed "Ride with the Devil" |
| 39% | ANG | 3 | Lee who directed "Ride With The Devil" |
| 39% | STOP | 4 | Signal made with the palm |
| 39% | SNAP | 4 | Sharp sound made with the fingers |
| 39% | UNHOLY | 6 | Like a pact with the Devil |
| 39% | ANG | 3 | "Ride With the Devil" director Lee |
| 39% | FAUSTIAN | 8 | Like a pact with the devil |
| 39% | DEMI | 4 | "Dancing With the Devil" singer Lovato |
| 39% | LEE | 3 | Ang ___, "Ride with the Devil" director |
| 39% | EVILONE | 7 | The Devil, with "the" |
| 38% | FAUST | 5 | Goethe character who makes a pact with the devil |
| 38% | BUTTERFLYKISSES | 15 | Expressions of affection made with the eyes |
| 38% | SNOOK | 5 | Gesture made with the thumb and nose |
| 38% | COSTUMEBALL | 11 | Occasion to dance with the devil, perhaps |
| 38% | IDLEHANDS | 9 | The devil's playthings, reportedly |
| 37% | WISH | 4 | It's often made with the eyes closed |
| 37% | PLANS | 5 | They're made with the help of maps |
| 37% | SNAP | 4 | Noise made with the thumb and middle finger |
| 37% | OLES | 4 | Shouts made with the waving of white hankies |
| 37% | SNAPS | 5 | Sounds made with the thumb and middle finger |
| 37% | SNAP | 4 | Sound made with the thumb and middle finger |
| 37% | WELL | 4 | ___ drink, bar offering made with the most inexpensive liquor |