| 100% | LIST | 4 | Something Santa makes (and checks twice) |
| 92% | LIST | 4 | What Santa makes and checks twice |
| 66% | LIST | 4 | What Santa's making (and checking twice) |
| 55% | ALIST | 5 | "He's making ___ and checking it twice ...": 2 wds. |
| 55% | ALIST | 5 | "He's making ___ and checking it twice ... " (2 wds.) |
| 53% | LIST | 4 | What Santa checks twice to see who's naughty and nice |
| 52% | ALIST | 5 | "He's making ___ and checking it twice" (Christmas song line): 2 wds. |
| 51% | SANTA | 5 | He makes a list and checks it twice |
| 51% | HES | 3 | "___ making a list and checking it twice ..." |
| 48% | LIST | 4 | "He's making a ___ and checking it twice ..." |
| 48% | LIST | 4 | "He's making a ___ and checking it twice . . ." |
| 48% | LIST | 4 | Something Santa or a shopper might check |
| 47% | LIST | 4 | Santa checks it twice |
| 46% | LIST | 4 | Santa checks his twice, in song |
| 45% | ALIST | 5 | "He's making ___, checking it twice ..." |
| 45% | VERIFYING | 9 | Checking, making sure something is legitimate |
| 45% | LISTS | 5 | What Santa makes for nice children and naughty children |
| 45% | LIST | 4 | What Santa's making and double-checking, in song |
| 44% | LIST | 4 | Something made by Santa labeled "Naughty" or "Nice" |
| 44% | SONG | 4 | Something that both Macklemore and Ryan Lewis make |
| 44% | LIST | 4 | What Santa checks twice |
| 43% | ALIST | 5 | "He's making ___ and checking ..." |
| 43% | CERAMIC | 7 | Something made from clay and fired in a kiln |
| 43% | WORKSHOP | 8 | Where Santa and his elves make toys |
| 43% | LISTS | 5 | They're made for and by Santa |
| 43% | SPAT | 4 | Something to kiss and make up after |
| 42% | CAMP | 4 | Something to make at night and break in the morning |
| 42% | PIE | 3 | Something you can make with pumpkins, pecans, peaches and pork |
| 41% | ACQUIRE | 7 | Get hold of something and make it your own |
| 40% | OPENACANOFWORMS | 15 | Attempt to fix something and inadvertently make the situation worse |