| 100% | DRAWL | 5 | Something that Lucas Black and Reese Witherspoon have in common |
| 54% | HORN | 4 | Something that a ram and a Ram have in common |
| 42% | DUI | 3 | Something that Sally Struthers, Kiefer Sutherland and Dick Cheney have in common (abbr.) |
| 42% | BLUE | 4 | Shade that the sky and the sea have in common |
| 41% | PADS | 4 | Something cats and hockey goalies have in common |
| 41% | ROMANNUMERALS | 13 | Something popes and Super Bowls have in common |
| 39% | LONGA | 5 | Something gays and straights have in common? |
| 39% | SYMMETRY | 8 | Something U and I have in common |
| 37% | WIRE | 4 | Something Peter Pan and Mary Poppins had in common in their movie appearances |
| 37% | POLIO | 5 | Something Neil Young and Jack Nicklaus have had in common |
| 37% | MBAS | 4 | Somethings Ina Garten and Shaquille O'Neal have in common |
| 36% | CHUTNEY | 7 | Spread that is common in Indian cuisine and that has a spicy coconut variant |
| 36% | EGO | 3 | Something Jane Goodall, Rube Goldberg and Nadine Gordimer have in common? |
| 35% | YALE | 4 | Something Bill Clinton and George W. Bush have in common |
| 34% | POEM | 4 | Something that might have rhyme and meter |
| 34% | AQUEOUS | 7 | Something that has been dissolved in water |
| 33% | BOARD | 5 | "Across the ___," common phrase meaning "affecting everything and everyone in a particular group," that has its origins in horse racing |
| 33% | BEANIEBABIES | 12 | Items in a 1990s Black Friday craze that had two separate ID tags: on the ear and on the tush |
| 33% | BADGER | 6 | Black and white mammal that lives in a sett |
| 33% | OVERLAP | 7 | Have something in common |
| 33% | XXXXXXX | 7 | Have something in common |
| 32% | TVAUDIENCE | 10 | Something that Nielsen determined has dropped considerably between 2014 and 2019 |
| 32% | GRANDPIANO | 10 | Something Liberace had that was covered in rhinestones |
| 31% | PET | 3 | Something that all but three U.S. presidents have had while in office |
| 31% | WAIL | 4 | Something that banshees and sirens do and either way, you're in trouble |
| 31% | BEE | 3 | Something black and yellow that can't see red |
| 31% | EXES | 4 | Something President Reagan has in common with President Trump |
| 31% | BREYERSICECREAM | 15 | … something soft and melty in a black tub |
| 31% | SOLOACT | 7 | Something David Copperfield has that Penn and Teller don't |
| 31% | PALMS | 5 | Trees that are common in California and Florida |