| 100% | SASH | 4 | Something the narrator of "A Visit From St. Nicholas" threw up |
| 59% | SASH | 4 | Part of a window thrown up in "A Visit From St. Nicholas" |
| 50% | TWAS | 4 | Start of "A Visit From St. Nicholas" |
| 49% | TWAS | 4 | First word of "A Visit From St. Nicholas" |
| 47% | CHRISTMAS | 9 | "'Twas the night before ___ ..." (start of "A Visit from St. Nicholas") |
| 47% | SASH | 4 | Window part that gets thrown up in "A Visit from St. Nicholas" |
| 46% | NESTLED | 7 | Like the children in "A Visit From St. Nicholas" |
| 46% | NOD | 3 | "And giving a ___, up the chimney he rose" ("A Visit From St. Nicholas" excerpt) |
| 46% | MOORE | 5 | Clement C. ___, writer of "A Visit From St. Nicholas" |
| 43% | PRANCER | 7 | Partner of Vixen in "A Visit From St. Nicholas" |
| 43% | PAPAL | 5 | Like a visit from the Bishop of Rome |
| 43% | GOODNIGHT | 9 | "... and to all a ___!" (end of "A Visit from St. Nicholas") |
| 43% | TWAS | 4 | "A Visit From St. Nicholas" opener |
| 43% | MOORE | 5 | "A Visit From St. Nicholas" poet |
| 43% | MOORE | 5 | "A Visit From St. Nicholas" writer |
| 43% | TOALLAGOODNIGHT | 15 | "A Visit From St. Nicholas" ending |
| 42% | TITLE | 5 | "A Visit From St. Nicholas," e.g. |
| 42% | POEM | 4 | "A Visit from St. Nicholas," for one |
| 42% | RECITED | 7 | Declaimed, as "A Visit From St. Nicholas" |
| 41% | ORATE | 5 | Perform "A Visit from St. Nicholas," for example |
| 41% | DASHER | 6 | First reindeer mentioned in "A Visit From St. Nicholas" |
| 41% | DANCER | 6 | Second reindeer mentioned in "A Visit From St. Nicholas" |
| 41% | DASHER | 6 | First reindeer named in “A Visit from St. Nicholas” |
| 40% | ALL | 3 | With 50-Down, like the children in "A Visit From St. Nicholas" |
| 40% | FIN | 3 | Part of a shark that sticks up from the water |
| 40% | VIXEN | 5 | Reindeer name "rhymed" with Blitzen in "A Visit From St. Nicholas" |
| 39% | DASH | 4 | "Now ___ away! ___ away! ___ away all!" (line in "A Visit From St. Nicholas") |
| 39% | OAR | 3 | Something thrown over the side of a boat |
| 37% | OMEN | 4 | Something interpreted from a bird's behavior, in the ancient Greek practice of ornithomancy |
| 36% | AROSE | 5 | "When out on the lawn there ___ such a clatter ..." ("A Visit From St. Nicholas") |