| 100% | FALLENEYELASH | 13 | Something to blow on to make a wish |
| 84% | BIRTHDAYCANDLE | 14 | Something to blow out to make a wish |
| 68% | CANDLE | 6 | Birthday ___, make a wish as you blow on these to make it come true |
| 62% | HAY | 3 | Something to make on a sunny day? |
| 61% | SHOOTING | 8 | The type of star you're told to make a wish on |
| 60% | KNEE | 4 | Something to make a proposal on? |
| 57% | CLOCK | 5 | Make a wish by seeing 11:11 on this timepiece to make it come true |
| 54% | WELL | 4 | Place to make a wish |
| 53% | WELL | 4 | Wishing ___ (place to toss coins while making a wish) |
| 52% | CHANGEOFHEART | 13 | Jodi Picoult novel about a man on trial for murder who wishes to make a life-saving organ donation (3 wds.) |
| 52% | WELLS | 5 | Places to get water or make a wish |
| 52% | SNACK | 5 | A little something to nosh on |
| 52% | EBOOK | 5 | Something to read on a Kindle |
| 52% | SUMMERBREEZE | 12 | Something to enjoy on a beach |
| 52% | YOYO | 4 | Something to swing on a string |
| 52% | EVENT | 5 | Something to write on a calendar |
| 52% | SHOELACE | 8 | Something to tie on a sneaker |
| 52% | ARM | 3 | Something to take on a date? |
| 52% | LOG | 3 | Something to throw on a fire |
| 52% | LOLLIPOP | 8 | Something to lick on a stick |
| 52% | BBC | 3 | Something to watch on a telly |
| 52% | IDOL | 4 | Something to put on a pedestal? |
| 52% | SKICAP | 6 | Something to wear on a run |
| 51% | BLEW | 4 | Made a wish, on a birthday cake |
| 51% | WISH | 4 | Something to make on one's birthday |
| 51% | SCARETACTIC | 11 | Something used to make a chicken stew? |
| 51% | PONCHO | 6 | Something to put on before a shower |
| 51% | USERNAME | 8 | Something to type on a login page |
| 51% | EBOOK | 5 | Something to read on a Kindle: Hyph. |
| 51% | BLOW | 4 | What you do to birthday candles after making a wish |