| 100% | BORROWED | 8 | Somethings old, new, __, and blue |
| 58% | URL | 3 | Something often underlined and blue |
| 57% | TESTAMENT | 9 | Something Old, something New? |
| 56% | BORROWED | 8 | Something old, something new, something __ |
| 53% | BIBLE | 5 | Old and New Testament |
| 53% | NOVELTY | 7 | Something new and unusual |
| 51% | BORROWED | 8 | "Something old, something new, something ___ ..." (wedding items) |
| 51% | NILE | 4 | River that Longfellow called “forever new and old” |
| 51% | REPURPOSE | 9 | Find a new and different use for something |
| 51% | ANTIQUE | 7 | Something that is old and collectible |
| 51% | ERAS | 4 | Times old and new |
| 50% | THEBIBLE | 8 | Old and New Testaments, together: 2 wds. |
| 49% | TESTAMENT | 9 | Bible is split into a new and an old one |
| 49% | TIMES | 5 | Something New York and Los Angeles each have |
| 49% | TESTAMENT | 9 | The King James Bible has a new and an old one |
| 48% | METS | 4 | New York MLB team with blue and orange uniforms |
| 48% | RETRONYM | 8 | New word for something old |
| 47% | MET | 3 | New York ballplayer with a blue and orange team logo |
| 47% | METS | 4 | New York baseball team whose uniforms are blue and orange |
| 47% | TESTAMENT | 9 | The Bible has an Old and New one |
| 47% | REALLOT | 7 | Divide in a new way and earmark something |
| 46% | NEW | 3 | "Something old, something ___, something borrowed, something blue," common superstitious saying related to weddings |
| 46% | FRESHAIR | 8 | Something new and different might be described as a breath of it |
| 45% | REBOOT | 6 | Bring back and make new, as an old movie franchise |
| 44% | BLAIR | 5 | Ben —, former rugby union fullback for New Zealand and Cardiff Blues |
| 43% | BIBLE | 5 | The —, collection of Christian scriptures consisting of the Old and New Testaments |
| 43% | VENTURE | 7 | ___ capital, money invested in a new business ... and something that involves 31a |
| 42% | RELIC | 5 | Something old |
| 42% | PASSE | 5 | Old news |
| 42% | TIDINGS | 7 | Old news? |