| 100% | VALENTINE | 9 | Song by 5 Seconds of Summer whose title is usually a recipient of a heart-shaped card |
| 39% | KISS | 4 | "___ Me," song by Ed Sheeran whose title is also "X" on a romantic card |
| 37% | YOUNGBLOOD | 10 | 2018 song by 5 Seconds of Summer that reached #1 in their home nation of Australia |
| 37% | PAM | 3 | "Polythene ___," 1969 song by The Beatles whose title was inspired by the nickname of a fan |
| 37% | LIKE | 4 | "I Really ___ You," song by Carly Rae Jepsen whose title is also a declaration of feelings |
| 37% | AMNESIA | 7 | 2014 song by 5 Seconds of Summer featuring the refrain, "'Cause I'm not fine at all" |
| 36% | HEART | 5 | "___-Shaped Box," horror novel written by Joe Hill whose title is inspired by a Nirvana song |
| 35% | ISIS | 4 | Bob Dylan song whose title is the name of a goddess |
| 34% | GLASS | 5 | With 27 Across, 2022 film whose title was inspired by a Beatles song |
| 34% | CRUSH | 5 | Song by David Archuleta whose title denotes a state of infatuation |
| 34% | IRIS | 4 | Song by Goo Goo Dolls whose title is part of an eye |
| 32% | ICANTSTANDIT | 12 | 1981 Eric Clapton song whose title is followed by "You're fooling around with my heart": 4 wds. |
| 32% | FIXINGAHOLE | 11 | "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band" song whose title is followed by "where the rain gets in" |
| 32% | SHE | 3 | "April Come ___ Will," 1966 song by Simon & Garfunkel whose title refers to a woman |
| 32% | TAKES | 5 | "It ___ Two," 1995 comedy movie starring the Olsen twins whose title is taken from a song by Marvin Gaye |
| 32% | AIR | 3 | "February ___," 2009 song by Lights whose title means a mixture of gases needed for breathing |
| 32% | MAD | 3 | 2008 song by Ne-Yo whose title is also a word for being upset that's often used to describe a bull's emotions |
| 32% | ECLIPSE | 7 | "Total ___ of the Heart," hit song by Bonnie Tyler with a celestial phenomenon in its title |
| 32% | WEST | 4 | "June on the ___ Coast," 1998 song by Bright Eyes whose title is the opposite of "east" |
| 32% | CRUELLA | 7 | Disney-reboot title character whose mother is pushed off a cliff by a pack of Dalmatians |
| 31% | PRETTYWOMAN | 11 | 1990 Garry Marshall film starring 17-Across and 28-Across whose title was inspired by a Roy Orbison song (2 wds.) |
| 31% | PETESAMPRAS | 11 | A retired American tennis legend whose record of 14 titles was only surpassed by Federer in 2009: 2 wds. |
| 31% | SHELOOKSSO | 10 | With 42-Across, 2014 debut single by 5 Seconds of Summer: 3 wds. |
| 31% | ILOVELUCY | 9 | Classic sitcom whose title was written in cursive over a heart (3 wds.) |
| 31% | OSLO | 4 | 2017 Tony-winning play whose title is also the name of a Norwegian city |
| 31% | BELIEVESINME | 12 | "She ___," a song by Kenny Rogers about a songwriter whose beloved is his biggest source of support: 3 wds. |
| 31% | UNO | 3 | Card game whose title is a Spanish word |
| 31% | LONDON | 6 | "___ Calling," song by British punk rock band the Clash which has the name of a city in its title that is known for the clock tower"Big Ben" |
| 30% | BARETTA | 7 | Nineteen-seventies cop show whose title character was a master of disguise |
| 30% | HAPPY | 5 | 2011 song by Pharrell Williams whose title is also a word for being joyful and describes the emotion behind a smile |