| 100% | AGONY | 5 | Song from Sondheim's "Into the Woods" |
| 61% | UNKNOWN | 7 | A song from Disney's Frozen 2, Into the __ |
| 59% | GROOVE | 6 | Into the __, Madonna song from 1985 |
| 59% | BEINGALIVE | 10 | Song from Sondheim's "Company" |
| 58% | AGONY | 5 | Into the Woods song with the lyric "Oh, the torture they teach" |
| 56% | SENDINTHECLOWNS | 15 | Song from Sondheim's "A Little Night Music" |
| 55% | AGONY | 5 | "Into the Woods" song |
| 53% | EVER | 4 | "___ After" ("Into the Woods" song) |
| 53% | SENDINTHECLOWNS | 15 | Song from Sondheim's "A Little Night Music" appropriate to this puzzle |
| 53% | NOONE | 5 | “___ Is Alone” (“Into the Woods” song) |
| 52% | AGONY | 5 | "Into the Woods" song sung by two princes |
| 52% | ONE | 3 | "No ___ Is Alone" ("Into the Woods" song) |
| 51% | STEPHENSSTILL | 13 | Sondheim's secret from the Feds |
| 51% | SUNFLOWER | 9 | 2018 Post Malone & Swae Lee song from the "Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse" soundtrack |
| 50% | AGONY | 5 | "Into the Woods" song sung by two princes |
| 49% | REACT | 5 | "Chemicals ___" (Aly & AJ song from "Into the Rush") |
| 49% | TRAIL | 5 | Way into the woods |
| 48% | BEINGALIVE | 10 | Song from "Company" that marks the show's climax |
| 48% | INTO | 4 | Sondheim's "___ the Woods" |
| 48% | SLICED | 6 | Drove into the woods, maybe |
| 48% | DAY | 3 | Jessica ___, bubbly teacher from the TV series "New Girl" who randomly breaks into songs |
| 48% | AGONY | 5 | Title feeling "beyond power of speech," in an "Into the Woods" song |
| 48% | OLDIE | 5 | Song that's a blast from the past |
| 47% | INTO | 4 | Sondheim's "____ the Woods" |
| 47% | RAP | 3 | Song from the 'hood |
| 47% | HYMN | 4 | Song from the choir |
| 47% | OLDIE | 5 | Song from the past |
| 47% | FROSTY | 6 | The snowman from Gene Autry's 1950 Christmas song |
| 47% | ASTIMEGOESBY | 12 | Song originally from the Broadway musical "Everybody's Welcome" |
| 47% | LETITGO | 7 | Elsa's song from the first Frozen movie |