| 100% | PLOP | 4 | Sound of a coin being tossed into a fountain |
| 65% | PLOP | 4 | Sound of a coin dropping into a fountain |
| 60% | PLOP | 4 | Sound of a rock being thrown into a pond |
| 56% | PLOP | 4 | Sound of a coin landing in a fountain |
| 50% | SPLAT | 5 | Sound of paint that's been tossed at a canvas |
| 50% | WISH | 4 | What accompanies tossing a coin into a fountain |
| 48% | WISH | 4 | What you make when tossing a coin into a fountain |
| 48% | WISH | 4 | Something to make when tossing a coin into a fountain |
| 48% | WISH | 4 | What you might make after tossing a coin into a fountain |
| 47% | ZAP | 3 | Sound of a mosquito being fried |
| 46% | FLIP | 4 | Toss of a coin |
| 45% | TREVI | 5 | Fountain into which, according to legend, one can toss a coin to guarantee a future return to Rome |
| 44% | SCENES | 6 | What each act of a play is divided into |
| 44% | COIN | 4 | It may be tossed in a fountain before a wish |
| 43% | INO | 3 | Mortal queen of Thebes who was transfigured into a goddess |
| 43% | PLOP | 4 | Sound of a frog jumping into a pond |
| 42% | PLANCHET | 8 | Metal disk to be made into a coin |
| 42% | TAILS | 5 | Side of a coin that is not "heads" |
| 42% | WISH | 4 | Something made while tossing a coin in a fountain |
| 42% | TAILS | 5 | Flip side of a coin that is not "heads" |
| 42% | HONEY | 5 | It may be drizzled into a cup of tea |
| 42% | TREVI | 5 | Fountain into which 6-Down were tossed |
| 41% | SPLASH | 6 | Sound of jumping into a pool, say |
| 41% | FINALPLAN | 9 | A completed course of action to be put into motion: 2 wds. |
| 41% | SOCK | 4 | Article of footwear that may be made into a puppet |
| 41% | CRUNCH | 6 | Sound of biting into a hard-shell taco |
| 41% | PENCE | 5 | Coins that are fractions of a 40-Across |
| 41% | SLED | 4 | Item tossed into a fire at the end of "Citizen Kane" |
| 41% | SCRAP | 5 | Bit of food that might be tossed to a pet dog |
| 40% | LOTSWIFE | 8 | She was turned into a pillar of salt, in the Bible |