| 100% | TIARA | 5 | Sparkling headpiece that crowns you as a magical being and completes your "Fairy" Halloween costume |
| 36% | DUST | 4 | Fairy ___, magical substance that you can sprinkle for a touch of enchantment with your "Fairy" Halloween costume |
| 33% | SQUAT | 5 | Leg workout in which you lower your body as if sitting in an invisible chair, and something that can be a part of your home workout |
| 31% | COSTUME | 7 | Kind of dress that helps kids act as monsters and is a common sight on Halloween |
| 30% | SATAN | 5 | Halloween costume that may involve horns and a tail |
| 30% | GHOST | 5 | Halloween costume that can be made from a sheet |
| 30% | TOGA | 4 | Halloween costume that can be made from a bedsheet |
| 29% | SATAN | 5 | Halloween costume that may involve a red cape and tail |
| 29% | MARIO | 5 | Halloween costume that often includes suspenders and a fake mustache |
| 29% | SATAN | 5 | Halloween costume that may involve a pitchfork, horns, and a tail |
| 28% | BELT | 4 | Utility ___, accessory that holds your tools and is a component of your "Superhero" Halloween costume |
| 27% | GODMOTHER | 9 | Cinderella's was a fairy and her magical mentor |
| 27% | SNUG | 4 | "___ as a bug in a rug," complete this phrase that you may use during "winter" |
| 27% | WAND | 4 | Magical object used for casting spells that would be a part of your "Harry Potter" Halloween costume |
| 27% | SUIT | 4 | Super ___, outfit you wear to fight crime that is a component of your "Superhero" Halloween costume |
| 27% | PAWS | 4 | Feline feet that may be a part of your "Cat" Halloween costume |
| 26% | NOVICE | 6 | As a Carthusian, wearing a dark cloak over your white habit; you are in all probability one of these |
| 26% | MASK | 4 | Face-covering accessory that hides your true identity and is a component of your "Superhero" Halloween costume |
| 26% | SWAB | 4 | The Q-tip that you shove in your ear is a small one |
| 26% | GEARS | 5 | Round, toothed elements that may be a part of your "Robot" Halloween costume |
| 26% | DRESS | 5 | Garment like a gown ... and something that might brush the floor as you walk |
| 26% | ECHO | 4 | Effect that lets you hear your own voice, as in a cave |
| 26% | COCONUT | 7 | Tropical fruit used as a vegan milk source, and that may be used as flavoring for a white popsicle |
| 26% | WINGS | 5 | Delicate and magical flight-related extensions you attach to your back for your "Fairy" Halloween costume |
| 26% | LAMP | 4 | (3/6) Magical fairy tale object that may be home to a wish-granting genie |
| 25% | HIRED | 5 | "You're ___!" words that you would be waiting to hear as you apply for your dream job |
| 25% | INNUENDO | 8 | "Is that a gun in your pocket, or are you just happy to see me?," e.g. |
| 25% | POTION | 6 | (4/6) Magical fairy tale concoction that may be brewed in a cauldron (rhymes with "motion") |
| 25% | TOMATO | 6 | Red ingredient that may be sun-dried and is a great addition to your breakfast sandwich |
| 25% | JELLY | 5 | *Make your Gingerbread village* Gel-like candy "bean" that you will need to make a pathway |