| 100% | JAM | 3 | Spread that often accompanies peanut butter |
| 57% | GHEE | 4 | Butter that often accompanies baati |
| 52% | ENERGYBAR | 9 | On-the-go snack that often comes in peanut butter |
| 45% | NOR | 3 | Word that often accompanies "neither" |
| 45% | TEE | 3 | Top that often accompanies joggers |
| 45% | TABOR | 5 | Drum that often accompanies a fife |
| 45% | DENTAL | 6 | Insurance type that often accompanies medical |
| 45% | TEA | 3 | Beverage that often accompanies dim sum |
| 45% | HOTTEA | 6 | Drink that often accompanies dim sum |
| 44% | JELLY | 5 | Fruity spread often paired with peanut butter |
| 44% | ZEAL | 4 | Word for "enthusiasm" that often accompanies "zest" |
| 44% | PEDI | 4 | Nail service that often accompanies a mani |
| 43% | SOY | 3 | Type of sauce that often accompanies Chinese dumplings |
| 43% | GPA | 3 | Number that often accompanies one's SAT score |
| 43% | JIF | 3 | Peanut butter that "choosy moms choose" |
| 43% | ITS | 3 | Word that often accompanies "complicated" while speaking of relationships |
| 43% | NAMASTE | 7 | Word that often accompanies the gesture called Anjali Mudra |
| 43% | YAKETYSAX | 9 | Novelty song that often accompanies sped-up chase scenes |
| 42% | JIF | 3 | Peanut butter brand that "choosy moms choose" |
| 42% | JIF | 3 | Peanut butter brand that some pronounce like "gif" |
| 42% | JIF | 3 | Maker of Whips peanut butter spreads |
| 40% | PEANUT | 6 | Salton ___ Butter Machine, vintage appliance to make a bread spread accompanied with jam that could be spotted in a '70s kitchen |
| 40% | JIF | 3 | Peanut butter brand that's almost the same upside down |
| 40% | JELLY | 5 | Peanut butter and ___, sandwich ingredients that "glue" bread slices together |
| 40% | JIF | 3 | Brand of peanut butter that "choosy moms choose" |
| 40% | POPCORN | 7 | Butter often accompanies this heated kernel |
| 40% | KNIFE | 5 | Utensil that can be used to spread peanut butter |
| 38% | CUP | 3 | Container that accompanies a saucer, often |
| 38% | BRR | 3 | Cold sound that accompanies teeth chattering, often |
| 37% | BRIE | 4 | French cheese that's often spread on crackers |