| 100% | EYES | 4 | Springfield’s Blinky the fish has three |
| 45% | ENS | 3 | The Nanny has three |
| 43% | MASTS | 5 | The Mayflower had three of them |
| 41% | SOS | 3 | It has three dashes in the middle |
| 41% | ANTICS | 6 | The Three Stooges had many |
| 40% | MASTS | 5 | The U.S.S. Constitution has three |
| 40% | DUCK | 4 | The Fat ___, chef Heston Blumenthal's restaurant in Bray which has earned three Michelin Stars |
| 38% | EEL | 3 | Fish hidden in the first three letters of "electricity" |
| 38% | GENDERS | 7 | The German language has three |
| 38% | CHANGINGDIAPERS | 15 | New father's task, maybe ... and what the three other longest puzzle answers have in common? |
| 37% | OZONE | 5 | The earth has a layer of it; three oxygen atoms |
| 37% | MANTAS | 6 | Fish that have been known to pass the mirror test |
| 37% | ONOFF | 5 | What the three longest answers have in common |
| 37% | CCC | 3 | What the three longest answers have in common |
| 37% | OUTS | 4 | Sometimes the ninth has only three |
| 37% | ENS | 3 | The word "nanny" has three |
| 36% | EEL | 3 | Fish some believe has been mistaken for the Loch Ness monster |
| 36% | MEDALIST | 8 | One who has placed top three at the Olympics |
| 36% | ELVER | 5 | Young fish that has migrated from the Sargasso Sea |
| 36% | GREATCODALMIGHTY | 16 | "This is the best fish I've ever had!" |
| 36% | LILWAYNE | 8 | "A Milli" rapper who's had top 10 hits in each of the last three decades: 2 wds. |
| 36% | TAYLORSWIFT | 11 | "Cardigan" pop singer who's had top 10 hits in each of the last three decades: 2 wds. |
| 36% | LADYGAGA | 8 | "Shallow" pop singer who's had top 10 hits in each of the last three decades: 2 wds. |
| 36% | ENAMEL | 6 | Fish has turned man - that's hard |
| 36% | MARIAHCAREY | 11 | "Honey" singer who's had three songs debut at #1 on the Billboard Hot 100: 2 wds. |
| 36% | SIMPSONS | 8 | Springfield's cartoon family, The __ |
| 36% | SALMON | 6 | Fish commonly served smoked, which has the ability to see infrared light |
| 36% | LID | 3 | Part of the eye that a fish doesn't have |
| 35% | SPANISH | 7 | The __ flag fish has red and yellow stripes |
| 35% | JASONDERULO | 11 | "Wiggle" R&B singer who's had top 10 hits in each of the last three decades: 2 wds. |