| 100% | ADDONS | 6 | Sprinkles and fudge at an ice cream parlor, e.g. |
| 52% | MALT | 4 | Order at an ice cream parlor |
| 52% | BANANASPLIT | 11 | Order at an ice cream parlor |
| 52% | CONES | 5 | Supply at an ice cream parlor |
| 51% | ADDIN | 5 | Oreos at an ice cream parlor, say |
| 50% | CONE | 4 | Alternative to a cup at an ice cream parlor |
| 50% | CONES | 5 | Edible alternatives to cups at an ice cream parlor |
| 45% | SCOOP | 5 | Portion at an ice-cream parlor |
| 45% | CONE | 4 | Option at an ice-cream parlor |
| 41% | SODA | 4 | Drink at an ice cream shop |
| 41% | SAMPLE | 6 | Freebie at an ice cream shop |
| 40% | CONE | 4 | Cup alternative, at an ice cream store |
| 40% | CONE | 4 | Cup alternative, at an ice cream shop |
| 40% | CONE | 4 | "Cup or ___?" (question at an ice cream shop) |
| 39% | ANDERSONSCOOPER | 15 | “360°” news anchor who works at an ice cream shop? |
| 38% | ORA | 3 | "In a cup ___ cone?" (question at an ice cream shop): 2 wds. |
| 38% | PARADEFLOAT | 11 | At the ice cream parlor, the grand marshal ordered a ... |
| 37% | ORA | 3 | "Would you like a cup ___ cone?" (question at an ice cream shop): 2 wds. |
| 35% | OREOSUNDAE | 10 | Cookies-and-cream option at an ice-cream shop |
| 35% | TURTLESUNDAE | 12 | Vanilla ice cream topped with caramel, fudge and pecans |
| 35% | MOOSETRACKS | 11 | Vanilla ice cream with peanut butter cups and fudge |
| 35% | CHORDS | 6 | G, D and E, at guitar lessons |
| 35% | ROCKYROAD | 9 | Nutty ice cream parlor order ... and a hint to each set of circled letters |
| 35% | TREAT | 5 | Ice cream sundae, e.g. |
| 35% | TREAT | 5 | Ice cream cone, e.g. |
| 34% | BIRTHDAYCAKE | 12 | Vanilla ice cream with buttercream frosting and sprinkles (2 wds.) |
| 34% | MOOSETRACKS | 11 | Vanilla ice cream with fudge swirls and peanut butter cups (2 wds.) |
| 33% | LILT | 4 | Ice cream truck music, e.g. |
| 33% | DESSERT | 7 | Ice cream or tiramisu, e.g. |
| 33% | SCOOPER | 7 | Ice cream shop employee, e.g. |