| 100% | BARTS | 5 | St. ___ (Caribbean island, for short) |
| 88% | BERMUDA | 7 | Caribbean island famous for its shorts |
| 72% | LUCIA | 5 | Caribbean island St ___ |
| 70% | LUCIA | 5 | St. ___, Caribbean island that was a wedding destination for celeb couples like Matt Damon and Luciana Barroso |
| 68% | IWO | 3 | Sulphur Island, for short |
| 67% | ANTIGUA | 7 | Caribbean island from the Spanish for "ancient" |
| 67% | BARTS | 5 | St. __: Caribbean island |
| 65% | IRE | 3 | Dublin's island, for short |
| 65% | TAH | 3 | Papeete's island, for short |
| 65% | TRINI | 5 | Certain Caribbean, for short |
| 64% | UKES | 4 | Island instruments, for short |
| 64% | UKE | 3 | Island strings, for short |
| 64% | UKES | 4 | Island strings, for short |
| 64% | UKE | 3 | Island instrument, for short |
| 64% | UKE | 3 | Islands instrument, for short |
| 63% | CARD | 4 | St. Louis ballplayer, for short |
| 62% | TORTUGA | 7 | Island setting for "Pirates of the Caribbean" |
| 60% | PETE | 4 | St. __ (Tampa neighbor, for short) |
| 60% | BARTS | 5 | St. ___ (Caribbean island, familiarly) |
| 60% | LUCIA | 5 | St. __ (Caribbean island nation) |
| 60% | UKES | 4 | Island music makers, for short |
| 60% | UKE | 3 | Island stringed instrument, for short |
| 60% | GRENADA | 7 | Island in the Caribbean, capital is St. George's |
| 59% | BERMUDA | 7 | ___ shorts (summer wear named for an Atlantic island) |
| 59% | LUCIA | 5 | St. ___ (Caribbean island near Martinique) |
| 59% | UMP | 3 | "St-rrrike!" caller, for short |
| 58% | IWO | 3 | One of the Volcano Islands, for short |
| 58% | IWO | 3 | One of the Bonin Islands, for short |
| 58% | KONG | 4 | Skull Island denizen, for short |
| 58% | KONG | 4 | Skull Island beast, for short |