| 100% | TORRE | 5 | Starting catcher in every All-Star Game from 1964 to 1967 |
| 37% | CAREW | 5 | All-Star 18 consecutive times from 1967 to 1984 |
| 32% | TENTH | 5 | Like the Mets in every season from 1962 to 1965 |
| 32% | AARON | 5 | Baseball All-Star every year from 1955 to 1975 |
| 31% | IMIT | 4 | Starting words from the tagger in a game of tag |
| 31% | TWO | 3 | Number of letters in every word of the answers to the starred clues |
| 31% | DARTS | 5 | Game in which players subtract from a starting score of 501 |
| 31% | JUMPBALL | 8 | Tip-off play used to start every basketball game |
| 31% | ROGERCLEMENS | 12 | Starting pitcher who pitched in a record 10 MLB All-Star Games (2 wds.) |
| 31% | REDO | 4 | To start all over, to work on something from scratch once more |
| 30% | ANAGRAMSOFNATIONNAMES | 21 | What the answers to the starred clues all start with |
| 30% | RUNIT | 5 | Rehearse a play from start to finish, in theater lingo |
| 30% | BOJACKSON | 9 | Only athlete to play in an MLB All-Star Game and an NFL Pro Bowl |
| 30% | RANIT | 5 | Rehearsed a piece through from start to finish, in theater lingo |
| 30% | ALFIE | 5 | To whom Dionne Warwick asked "What's it all about?" in a 1967 hit |
| 30% | NIM | 3 | Game for two in which players take turns to remove matches from several rows |
| 29% | LIN | 3 | Basketball star Jeremy traded from the Knicks to the Rockets in 2012 |
| 29% | EAST | 4 | Side in an all-star game |
| 29% | MAYS | 4 | #24 in 24 All-Star Games |
| 29% | EAST | 4 | Side in some all-star games |
| 29% | HOME | 4 | Where you try to move all your tokens, in a game of Sorry! |
| 29% | CRAZYEIGHTS | 11 | Simple card game, and what's hidden in the answers to starred clues |
| 29% | ANTONRODGERS | 12 | Actor who starred in BBC TV sitcom May to December from 1989-94 |
| 29% | BOX | 3 | Start to "car" to give a yellow train card in the board game "Ticket to Ride" |
| 29% | SPYFALL | 7 | Game in which one player tries to glean information from the other players without being caught |
| 29% | DAYANDNIGHT | 11 | All the time, as well as a hint to the abbreviations hidden in the starred answers |
| 28% | TELEPHONE | 9 | Game in which words can change from person to person |
| 28% | MUSIAL | 6 | One of three men to play in 24 All-Star Games, with Aaron and Mays |
| 28% | JUGBAND | 7 | *Where the starts of the answers to the five starred clues can all be found |
| 28% | KELSEY | 6 | Plum who was the WNBA All-Star Game MVP in 2022 |