| 100% | ROGERCLEMENS | 12 | Starting pitcher who pitched in a record 10 MLB All-Star Games (2 wds.) |
| 58% | MARIANORIVERA | 13 | Relief pitcher who saved a record four MLB All-Star Games (2 wds.) |
| 57% | DONLARSEN | 9 | Yankees pitcher who pitched a perfect game in the World Series on 10/8/56: 2 wds. |
| 49% | HANKAARON | 9 | 1982 Cooperstown inductee who appeared in a record 25 All-Star Games (2 wds.) |
| 47% | ORELHERSHISER | 13 | Pitcher who holds the MLB all-time record with 59 straight scoreless innings pitched (2 wds.) |
| 47% | RANDYAROZARENA | 14 | Rays outfielder who slugged a record 10 home runs in the 2020 MLB postseason: 2 wds. |
| 44% | JESSEOROSCO | 11 | He pitched in a record 1,252 games for nine teams, including the Mets, from 1979 to 2003: 2 wds. |
| 44% | DAVIDCONE | 9 | Yankees pitcher who threw a perfect game in 1999: 2 wds. |
| 44% | DOMINGOGERMAN | 13 | Yankees pitcher who threw a perfect game in 2023: 2 wds. |
| 44% | HANKAARON | 9 | Braves right fielder/first baseman who had All-Star Game appearances in a record 21 seasons: 2 wds. |
| 44% | DONLARSEN | 9 | Yankees pitcher who threw a perfect game in the 1956 World Series: 2 wds. |
| 44% | BENZOBRIST | 10 | Cubs second baseman who started the 2016 MLB All-Star Game: 2 wds. |
| 44% | ANTHONYRIZZO | 12 | Cubs first baseman who started the 2016 MLB All-Star Game: 2 wds. |
| 44% | KRISBRYANT | 10 | Cubs third baseman who started the 2016 MLB All-Star Game: 2 wds. |
| 44% | JACOBDEGROM | 11 | Mets starting pitcher who won the NL Cy Young Award in 2018 with only 10 wins: 2 wds. |
| 43% | NOLANRYAN | 9 | Pitcher who had a record seven no-hitters and played to age 46, in 1993: 2 wds. |
| 42% | DAVIDCONE | 9 | Yankees pitcher who pitched a perfect game on 7/18/99, a day honoring 23-Down at Yankee Stadium: 2 wds. |
| 42% | SHOHEIOHTANI | 12 | Japanese MLB player who was the first player in history to be a pitcher and hitter in the All-Star Game, in 2021: 2 wds. |
| 41% | MARIANORIVERA | 13 | Pitcher who holds the MLB all-time record with 652 saves (2 wds.) |
| 41% | OROSCO | 6 | Jesse who pitched in a record 1,252 major-league games |
| 40% | JOHNCENA | 8 | American wrestler with a record 13 WWE Championships, who has also released his own rap albums and starred in films: 2 wds. |
| 40% | NOLANRYAN | 9 | Pitcher who holds the MLB all-time record with 5,714 strikeouts and seven no-hitters (2 wds.) |
| 39% | JACKWAGNER | 10 | "General Hospital" star who had a top 10 hit with "All I Need" in 1984: 2 wds. |
| 39% | BRETTFAVRE | 10 | Packers/Jets/Vikings player who started 297 consecutive games, a record among all quarterbacks: 2 wds. |
| 39% | RIPKEN | 6 | Oriole who played in a record 2,632 straight games |
| 39% | STARLINCASTRO | 13 | Yankees second baseman, who is a three-time All-Star and holds a record for most runs batted in an MLB debut : 2 wds. |
| 38% | GERRITCOLE | 10 | Pitcher who signed a $324 million contract with the Yankees in 2019: 2 wds. |
| 38% | DAVIDPRICE | 10 | Red Sox pitcher who won two games in the 2018 World Series with a 1.98 ERA (2 wds.) |
| 38% | JOHNNYBENCH | 11 | Reds catcher who was a 10-time All-Star in the 1970s: 2 wds. |
| 38% | GEORGELOPEZ | 11 | Comedian who starred in a self-titled sitcom from 2002 to 2007, and another that started in 2016: 2 wds. |