| 100% | SACRILEGE | 9 | Stealing from the collection plate, for example |
| 71% | SACRILEGE | 9 | Stealing from the collection plate, e.g. |
| 51% | AIL | 3 | Suffer from the flu, for example |
| 47% | ART | 3 | The Guggenheim collection, for example |
| 47% | CHEAT | 5 | Surreptitiously take money from the bank in Monopoly, for example |
| 46% | SQUEAKYTOY | 10 | Three-eyed alien from the Pizza Planet claw machine, for example |
| 46% | ALIBI | 5 | "I was far from the crime scene," for example |
| 41% | GAVE | 4 | Added to the collection plate |
| 41% | GAVE | 4 | Dropped into the collection plate |
| 41% | POOR | 4 | Steal from the rich and give to the ___ |
| 40% | ITSAGOODTITHING | 15 | Observation when the collection plate is overflowing? |
| 40% | THEROADNOTTAKEN | 15 | Classic verse from the collection "Mountain Interval" |
| 40% | BILBO | 5 | Character who steals from the dragon Smaug |
| 40% | MONALISA | 8 | Painting stolen from the Louvre in 1911 |
| 39% | TART | 4 | Small pastry stolen from the Queen of Hearts |
| 39% | PORRIDGE | 8 | Eaten by Goldilocks, stolen from the Three Bears |
| 39% | EATEN | 5 | Gone from the plate |
| 39% | THROWITHOME | 11 | Plea from the plate |
| 38% | HEADUSHER | 9 | One might be in charge of the collection plates |
| 38% | ROBINHOOD | 9 | He stole from the rich, gave to the poor |
| 38% | ARIA | 4 | Song from "The Magic Flute," for example |
| 38% | NERD | 4 | Chidi from "The Good Place," for example |
| 38% | EATEN | 5 | All gone from the plate |
| 38% | PATENS | 6 | Ceremonial plates for the Eucharist |
| 38% | SHAME | 5 | Feeling after being caught stealing from the cookie jar, maybe |
| 38% | ROBINHOOD | 9 | He steals from the rich and gives to the poor |
| 38% | ROBINHOOD | 9 | He stole from the rich to give to the poor |
| 38% | BEANSTALK | 9 | Jack climbed this to steal from the giant's castle |
| 38% | MONALISA | 8 | Famous work of art stolen from the Louvre in 1911 |
| 37% | EMIR | 4 | Word from the Arabic for ''commander'' |