| 100% | LORE | 4 | Stories that may or may not be true |
| 75% | TALE | 4 | Exciting story that may not be completely true |
| 74% | LORE | 4 | Stories that might not be true |
| 69% | ITS | 3 | Word that may or may not be apostrophized |
| 68% | WERE | 4 | Word that may or may not be a contraction |
| 68% | ILL | 3 | Word that may or may not be a contraction |
| 66% | UFOS | 4 | Vehicles that may or may not be stored in Area 51: Abbr. |
| 61% | DANQUAYLE | 9 | Veep who said "We are ready for any unforeseen event that may or may not occur" |
| 57% | HITORMISS | 9 | May or may not be successful |
| 56% | ALIBI | 5 | Story that one generally sticks to, whether it's true or not |
| 55% | ENDLESS | 7 | What the universe may or may not be |
| 55% | CHILI | 5 | Dish that may or may not contain beans |
| 54% | ITS | 3 | Word that may or may not contain an apostrophe |
| 54% | SLAW | 4 | Side dish that may or may not include mayo |
| 53% | BUBBLETEAMS | 11 | Squads that may or may not participate in March Madness |
| 53% | RESTRAINT | 9 | It might or might not be displayed at a candy store |
| 52% | MYTH | 4 | Stories that may be busted |
| 52% | TALES | 5 | Stories that may be ''tall'' |
| 52% | TALES | 5 | Stories that may be "tall" |
| 52% | TALES | 5 | Stories that might be ''tall'' |
| 52% | TALES | 5 | Stories that might be "tall" |
| 52% | TALE | 4 | Story that may be tall |
| 52% | TALE | 4 | Story that may be ''tall'' |
| 52% | ATTIC | 5 | Story that may be unfinished |
| 52% | TALE | 4 | Story that might be tall |
| 52% | TALE | 4 | Story that might be ''tall'' |
| 52% | TALE | 4 | Story that might be "tall" |
| 52% | TALE | 4 | Story that might be "cautionary" |
| 52% | ALIBI | 5 | Story that might be "airtight" |
| 52% | LSD | 3 | What "Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds" may or may not be about |