| 100% | YENTL | 5 | Story subtitled "The Yeshiva Boy" |
| 63% | YENTL | 5 | Isaac Bashevis Singer story "___ the Yeshiva Boy" |
| 55% | ANDY | 4 | Boy in the "Toy Story" films |
| 53% | ANDY | 4 | Boy who owns the toys in "Toy Story" |
| 52% | JUNGLE | 6 | The __ Book, story about a boy raised by animals |
| 52% | ASYLUM | 6 | Subtitle of the second season of "American Horror Story" |
| 52% | COVEN | 5 | Subtitle of the third season of "American Horror Story" |
| 52% | HOTEL | 5 | Subtitle of the fifth season of "American Horror Story" |
| 51% | THESLIPPER | 10 | & 7D 1976 family film starring Richard Chamberlain subtitled The Story of Cinderella |
| 50% | FREAKSHOW | 9 | Subtitle of the fourth season of "American Horror Story": 2 wds. |
| 50% | EGOTISM | 7 | Nathaniel Hawthorne story subtitled "The Bosom-Serpent" |
| 49% | THEDESERTFOX | 12 | 1951 biopic subtitled The Story of Rommel starring James Mason in the title role |
| 49% | ONEL | 4 | Book subtitled The Turbulent True Story of a First Year at Harvard Law School |
| 48% | QUEEN | 5 | 1905 children's book by L Frank Baum subtitled The Story of the Magic Cloak |
| 48% | SONOFTHEWOLF | 12 | The —, 1900 story collection by Jack London subtitled Tales of the Far North |
| 48% | ANDY | 4 | Boy's name on the sole of Woody's boot in "Toy Story" |
| 47% | QUEEN | 5 | & 1D 1905 children's book by L Frank Baum subtitled The Story of the Magic Cloak |
| 47% | MURDER | 6 | With 23-Across, subtitle of the first season of "American Horror Story" |
| 47% | PETERPAN | 8 | Classic story of The Boy Who Wouldn't Grow Up |
| 45% | AIDA | 4 | Broadway musical subtitled "The Timeless Love Story" |
| 45% | ONLY | 4 | & 19D The —, 1978 Nell Dunn novel subtitled A Simple Story of Heaven and Hell |
| 45% | DIKE | 4 | What the little Dutch boy stuck his finger in, in a kid's story |
| 44% | AXL | 3 | 2018 sci-fi movie which follows the story of a boy and a robotic dog |
| 44% | LARA | 4 | Book subtitled "The Untold Love Story and the Inspiration for Doctor Zhivago" |
| 43% | OFA | 3 | "This is the story ___ boy and a girl...": 2 wds. |
| 43% | THEFRYERSTALE | 13 | Story subtitled "Murder Most Fowl"? |