| 100% | EGGNOG | 6 | Sugar, milk, brandy and an ovum at Christmas |
| 33% | TURKEYS | 7 | Poultry birds eaten at Christmas and Thanksgiving |
| 33% | PECANPIE | 8 | Nutty dessert eaten at Christmas and Thanksgiving |
| 32% | EGGNOG | 6 | Drink of eggs, milk, sugar, spice and brandy that can be served hot or cold |
| 31% | ICECREAM | 8 | Frozen dessert made of sugar, milk and flavoring |
| 31% | CHAI | 4 | Tea made with milk, sugar and cardamom |
| 31% | CARAMELS | 8 | Chewy sweets with butter, milk and sugar |
| 31% | COCOA | 5 | Hot drink at an outdoor Christmas market |
| 31% | HAMS | 4 | Meats often eaten at Easter and Christmas |
| 31% | CATER | 5 | Provide food and drink at an event |
| 30% | RIZAULAIT | 9 | French dessert made with rice, milk and sugar |
| 30% | FUDGE | 5 | Candy made primarily with sugar, butter, and milk |
| 30% | LECHE | 5 | Dulce de ___ (spread made from milk and sugar) |
| 30% | EGGNOG | 6 | Brandy or rum added to whipped dairy products and sugar, basically |
| 30% | HARDSAUCE | 9 | Butter and sugar mixture usually containing brandy or rum |
| 30% | CARAMEL | 7 | Melted butter, sugar and milk for a soft center |
| 30% | MERINGUE | 8 | Egg whites and sugar dessert cooked at low temps |
| 29% | ALLKIDDINGASIDE | 15 | The mischievous actor winked at the audience and delivered an ___ |
| 29% | DISCUS | 6 | Round object thrown at an Olympic track and field event |
| 29% | ADDONS | 6 | Sprinkles and fudge at an ice cream parlor, e.g. |
| 28% | TIFFANY | 7 | "Come and trim my Christmas tree / With some decorations bought at ___" |
| 28% | SANTA | 5 | Milk and cookies recipient on Christmas Eve |
| 28% | DEPTHBOMB | 9 | Calvados and brandy for an underwater explosion |
| 28% | BAKING | 6 | Aisle at the supermarket where one can purchase flour, icing, and sugar |
| 28% | IDO | 3 | Words said at an altar by the Bride and Groom: 2 wds |
| 28% | CUSTARD | 7 | Sweet sauce made with milk, eggs and sugar |
| 28% | EGGNOG | 6 | Beverage made with eggs, milk, cream, and sugar |
| 27% | LIWET | 5 | Nasi ___, an Indonesian rice dish cooked in coconut milk, chicken broth, and spices |
| 27% | CAFECONLECHE | 12 | Spanish or Portuguese dark roasted coffee mixed with sugar and served with heated milk |
| 26% | WREATH | 6 | Circle of flowers and leaves, popular at Christmas |