| 100% | ROAST | 5 | Sunday dinner that's "mixed up" in four answers |
| 44% | GEM | 3 | Stone that's "cut" in this puzzle's four longest answers |
| 40% | STEW | 4 | Hearty dinner that's served in a bowl |
| 39% | EVE | 3 | Day before that's found in the starred answers |
| 39% | CAKEBATTER | 10 | Mix up in the kitchen? |
| 39% | OILANDWATER | 11 | Substances that never mix, except in the answers to the starred clues? |
| 39% | TOSSACOIN | 9 | Perform a pregame NFL ritual ... or, in four parts, phrase that hints at seven long Across answers |
| 38% | THEIDES | 7 | Date that provides a phonetic hint to four other answers in this puzzle |
| 38% | PCORMAC | 7 | What's hidden in the four longest Across answers |
| 38% | AFRICA | 6 | Continent that's in all four hemispheres |
| 37% | OWO | 3 | Surprised emoticon hidden in four of this puzzle's answers |
| 37% | AUDIO | 5 | A duo I mixed up in hearing |
| 36% | NRA | 3 | Org. that's up in arms? |
| 35% | AID | 3 | Helping hand that's been "lent" to the four longest answers |
| 35% | SQUEEZEPLAY | 11 | Risky baseball strategy that's indicated four times in this puzzle? |
| 35% | MEMO | 4 | Office note hidden in four of the Across answers |
| 35% | ANIMALCRACKERS | 14 | Lunchbox treat that contains the four beasts hidden in this grid, and what the starred answers literally are |
| 35% | ALPO | 4 | Dinner that typically comes in a bowl |
| 35% | EIEIO | 5 | Children's song refrain featured in the four longest answers |
| 35% | RVTRADEIN | 9 | Camper upgrade, literally seen in four puzzle answers |
| 34% | NEWS | 4 | Word that's only coincidentally made up of the four main compass points |
| 34% | NDA | 3 | Confidentiality contract initials found in this puzzle's four longest answers |
| 34% | LONG | 4 | Word interpreted literally in completing four of this puzzle's answers |
| 34% | NUT | 3 | What's ''cracked'' in each of the four star-paired answers |
| 34% | LUMOS | 5 | Magical spell in "Harry Potter" that lights up one's wand |
| 34% | GARANIMALS | 10 | Children’s clothing line that specializes in mix-and-match separates |
| 34% | PEOPLEOFTHECLOTH | 16 | Clergy ... and four answers in this puzzle? |
| 34% | ENEMY | 5 | Foe found phonetically in four puzzle answers |
| 34% | STIRRING | 8 | How witches mix up ingredients in cauldrons |
| 34% | HAMLET | 6 | Speaker of the quote that's found in the middle of the starred answers |