| 100% | TOAD | 4 | Super Mario Bros. character who resembles a mushroom |
| 83% | TOAD | 4 | Super Mario Bros. character who looks like a mushroom |
| 71% | TOAD | 4 | Super Mario Bros. character with a mushroom head |
| 56% | TOAD | 4 | Super Mario character with a mushroom-like head |
| 54% | TOADETTE | 8 | Childlike character in the Super Mario games who wears a pink dress with a pink mushroom hat |
| 48% | TOAD | 4 | "The Super Mario Bros. Movie" character |
| 46% | KOOPA | 5 | Super Mario creature that resembles a turtle |
| 46% | YOSHI | 5 | Super Mario character who can swallow enemies |
| 46% | WALUIGI | 7 | Purple-clad character who serves as a foil to Mario's brother in the "Super Mario Bros." series |
| 45% | JOHN | 4 | ___ Leguizamo, "Super Mario Bros." actor who portrays the role of a Movie Star in "The Menu" |
| 43% | ROSALINA | 8 | Magical character in the Super Mario games who wears a turquoise dress with a silver crown |
| 43% | PEACH | 5 | Princess ___, "Super Mario Bros." character |
| 42% | PRINCESSPEACH | 13 | Royal character in the Super Mario games who wears a pink dress with a gold crown: 2 wds. |
| 41% | TOAD | 4 | Mario character with a mushroom head |
| 41% | TOADETTE | 8 | Mario franchise character with a pink outfit and a mushroom head |
| 41% | TOAD | 4 | Mario character with a mushroom-like head |
| 40% | JACKBLACK | 9 | "The Super Mario Bros. Movie" voice actor who plays guitarist and substitute teacher Dewey in 29-Across (2 wds.) |
| 40% | CASTLE | 6 | Setting for many a Super Mario Bros. level |
| 40% | NES | 3 | Super Mario Bros. player |
| 40% | NES | 3 | Super Mario Bros. letters |
| 40% | NES | 3 | Super Mario Bros. runner |
| 40% | NES | 3 | Super Mario Bros. console |
| 40% | NES | 3 | Super Mario Bros. platform |
| 40% | YOSHI | 5 | Super Mario Bros. dinosaur |
| 40% | NINTENDO | 8 | Super Mario Bros. company |
| 39% | TOADETTE | 8 | Mario character with a mushroom head and pink braids |
| 39% | NES | 3 | Super Mario Bros. console: Abbr. |
| 39% | NES | 3 | Super Mario Bros. 3 console |
| 39% | NES | 3 | Super Mario Bros. 2 console |
| 39% | KOOLAIDMAN | 10 | Character who bursts through a window to join a stampede of wiener dogs in a 2025 Super Bowl ad |