| 100% | TOAD | 4 | Super Mario Bros. character with a mushroom head |
| 80% | TOAD | 4 | Super Mario character with a mushroom-like head |
| 74% | TOAD | 4 | Mario character with a mushroom head |
| 72% | TOADETTE | 8 | Mario character with a mushroom head and pink braids |
| 71% | TOAD | 4 | Super Mario Bros. character who resembles a mushroom |
| 70% | TOAD | 4 | Super Mario Bros. character who looks like a mushroom |
| 70% | TOAD | 4 | Mario character with a mushroom-like head |
| 68% | TOADETTE | 8 | Mario franchise character with a pink outfit and a mushroom head |
| 61% | TOAD | 4 | Mario Kart character with a mushroomlike head |
| 52% | TOADETTE | 8 | Childlike character in the Super Mario games who wears a pink dress with a pink mushroom hat |
| 48% | TOAD | 4 | "The Super Mario Bros. Movie" character |
| 47% | DRMARIO | 7 | Nintendo title character with a head mirror |
| 46% | SIM | 3 | Video game character with a plumbob above their head |
| 46% | YOSHI | 5 | Super Mario dinosaur with a long tongue |
| 46% | SHYGUY | 6 | Super Mario enemy with a rhyming name |
| 45% | WALUIGI | 7 | Mario character with a purple hat and handlebar mustache |
| 43% | RAGU | 4 | Pasta sauce brand with a Super Chunky Mushroom variety |
| 43% | PEACH | 5 | Princess ___, "Super Mario Bros." character |
| 43% | BIRDO | 5 | Pink creature with a red bow in Super Mario games |
| 42% | HEYARNOLD | 9 | Nickelodeon TV show with a main character often called "Football Head" |
| 42% | ROSALINA | 8 | Magical character in the Super Mario games who wears a turquoise dress with a silver crown |
| 42% | SMASH | 5 | Super ___ Bros. Ultimate (video game with Mario, Pikachu, and others) |
| 41% | PRINCESSPEACH | 13 | Royal character in the Super Mario games who wears a pink dress with a gold crown: 2 wds. |
| 40% | CASTLE | 6 | Setting for many a Super Mario Bros. level |
| 40% | KOOPA | 5 | Adorable but antagonistic Mario character with a shell |
| 40% | BOPEEP | 6 | Toy Story character with a three-headed sheep |
| 40% | NES | 3 | Super Mario Bros. player |
| 40% | NES | 3 | Super Mario Bros. letters |
| 40% | NES | 3 | Super Mario Bros. runner |
| 40% | NES | 3 | Super Mario Bros. console |