| 100% | ANEMONE | 7 | Tentacled sea creature with a hard-to-pronounce name |
| 54% | ANEMONE | 7 | Flower that shares its name with a tentacled sea creature |
| 51% | LONGJOHNSILVER | 14 | Pirate with a hard-to-rhyme name |
| 51% | WILLIAMOFORANGE | 15 | King with a hard-to-rhyme name |
| 51% | THECOLORPURPLE | 14 | Movie with a hard-to-rhyme name |
| 50% | GRAYWHALE | 9 | Sea creature with a double blowhole |
| 50% | ORCA | 4 | Sea creature with a saddle patch |
| 48% | CLAM | 4 | Sea creature with a shell (it's usually baked) |
| 48% | SWORDFISH | 9 | Predatory sea creature with a pointed protrusion |
| 47% | SQUID | 5 | Fast-moving sea creature with a torpedo-shaped body |
| 46% | SEACUCUMBER | 11 | *Marine creature with a tentacled mouth |
| 44% | ANEMONE | 7 | Sea creature named after a flower |
| 44% | ANEMONE | 7 | Sea creature named for a plant |
| 44% | ANEMONE | 7 | Flower that shares its name with a sea creature |
| 44% | HYDRAS | 6 | Sea creatures named for a mythical monster |
| 44% | NARWHAL | 7 | Sea creature with the scientific name Monodon monoceros ("one tooth, one horn") |
| 43% | ANEMONES | 8 | Sea creatures named for their resemblance to flowers |
| 43% | PEAS | 4 | Items hard to eat with a knife |
| 42% | IONIA | 5 | Ancient land with a sea named after it |
| 42% | BARENTS | 7 | Navigator William with a sea named after him |
| 42% | ENT | 3 | Tall creature with a page on The One Wiki to Rule Them All |
| 42% | CRAB | 4 | Sea creature whose name doesn't rhyme with 1-Across, weirdly |
| 41% | PEA | 3 | Vegetable that's hard to eat with a knife |
| 41% | PEA | 3 | Vegetable that's hard to spear with a fork |
| 41% | PEA | 3 | Veggie that's hard to eat with a fork |
| 41% | PEA | 3 | Legume that's hard to eat with a fork |
| 41% | DELHI | 5 | Indian city with a similar name to the capital |
| 41% | CANTSAYSURE | 11 | Is unable to pronounce the name of a deodorant brand? |
| 41% | PEA | 3 | Small vegetable that's hard to stab with a fork |
| 41% | FOGS | 4 | Gets hard to see through, in a way, with "up" |