| 100% | MAGISTRATE | 10 | The —, 1885 stage farce by Arthur Wing Pinero |
| 58% | DANDYDICK | 9 | 1887 stage play by Arthur Wing Pinero |
| 40% | PINERO | 6 | Arthur Wing —, author of stage plays The Gay Lord Quex and The Second Mrs Tanqueray |
| 36% | THARK | 5 | 1927 stage farce by Ben Travers |
| 36% | ROOKERYNOOK | 11 | 1926 stage farce by Ben Travers |
| 32% | YENTE | 5 | Stage role originated by Bea Arthur |
| 32% | SEEHOW | 6 | & 23A 1944 stage farce by Philip King adapted as a film in 1955 |
| 31% | SITIN | 5 | Protest staged by the Greensboro Four |
| 31% | SIDECAR | 7 | Cognac cocktail ordered by Arthur Ruskin in "Bonfire of the Vanities" |
| 30% | OBIEAWARDS | 10 | Honors bestowed by the American Theatre Wing |
| 30% | OBIES | 5 | Honors presented by the American Theatre Wing |
| 30% | OBIES | 5 | Awards presented by the American Theatre Wing |
| 30% | OBIE | 4 | Award presented by the American Theatre Wing |
| 30% | SCHNITZLER | 10 | Arthur —, author of stage plays Reigen and The Green Cockatoo |
| 30% | OBIE | 4 | Award co-presented by the American Theatre Wing |
| 30% | OURTOWN | 7 | Thornton Wilder play narrated by the Stage Manager |
| 29% | SILLY | 5 | "___ Love Songs," a hit love song by the Wings |
| 29% | RAMA | 4 | "Rendezvous with ___," 1973 novel by Arthur C. Clarke that is set in the 2130s |
| 29% | EXCALIBUR | 9 | Sword handed to Arthur by the Lady of the Lake |
| 29% | NEUTRINO | 8 | Particle studied by the Nobel Prize winner Arthur B. McDonald |
| 29% | OBIE | 4 | Award co-administered by the American Theater Wing since 2014 |
| 29% | BLUEROOM | 8 | The —, 1998 stage play by David Hare |
| 29% | HOSTAGE | 7 | The —, 1958 stage play by Brendan Behan |
| 29% | KNACK | 5 | The —, 1961 stage play by Ann Jellicoe |
| 29% | SEA | 3 | The —, 1973 stage play by Edward Bond |
| 29% | KITCHEN | 7 | The —, 1959 stage play by Arnold Wesker |
| 29% | SKINGAME | 8 | The —, 1920 stage play by John Galsworthy |
| 29% | WEIR | 4 | The —, 1997 stage play by Conor McPherson |