| 100% | UNINVITED | 9 | The —, 2009 horror starring Emily Browning and Arielle Kebbel |
| 43% | SUCKERPUNCH | 11 | 2011 action film starring Emily Browning and Abbie Cornish |
| 39% | DRAGMETOHELL | 12 | 2009 horror film starring Alison Lohman and Justin Long |
| 39% | THEUNBORN | 9 | 2009 horror movie starring Odette Yustman and Gary Oldman |
| 36% | BOXER | 5 | The —, 1997 film drama starring Daniel Day-Lewis and Emily Watson |
| 36% | RELIC | 5 | The —, 1997 horror film starring Penelope Ann Miller and Tom Sizemore |
| 35% | BREED | 5 | The —, 2006 horror starring Michelle Rodriguez and Taryn Manning |
| 35% | PROPOSAL | 8 | The —, 2009 romcom starring Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds |
| 34% | AQUIETPLACE | 11 | 2018 horror film starring Emily Blunt and John Krasinski |
| 34% | FACULTY | 7 | The —, 1998 horror/sci-fi film starring Elijah Wood, Jordana Brewster and Clea DuVall |
| 33% | PIT | 3 | "The ___ and the Pendulum," 1961 horror film starring Vincent Price that has gothic elements |
| 33% | PRINCESS | 8 | & 10D The —, 2009 animated film starring the voice talent of Anika Noni Rose and Bruno Campos |
| 33% | DEVIL | 5 | "Flesh and the ___," 1926 silent film directed by Clarence Brown that stars Greta Garbo |
| 32% | THEYOUNG | 8 | 2009 historical drama film starring Emily Blunt in the title role |
| 32% | BOX | 3 | The —, 2009 mystery film starring Cameron Diaz and James Marsden |
| 32% | INFORMANT | 9 | The —, 2009 comedy film starring Matt Damon and Scott Bakula |
| 32% | FIRM | 4 | The —, 2009 film drama starring Paul Anderson and Calum McNab |
| 32% | BOX | 3 | The —, 2009 film drama starring Cameron Diaz and James Marsden |
| 31% | REBOUND | 7 | "The ___," 2009 romantic movie starring Catherine Zeta Jones and Justin Bartha |
| 31% | CRYPT | 5 | "Tales from the ___," horror anthology TV series starring notable actors like Catherine O'Hara and Daniel Craig |
| 31% | LASTSTATION | 11 | The —, 2009 biographical drama film starring Helen Mirren and Christopher Plummer |
| 31% | SKULL | 5 | The —, 1965 horror film starring Peter Cushing and Patrick Wymark |
| 31% | BROOD | 5 | The —, 1979 horror film starring Oliver Reed and Samantha Eggar |
| 31% | TINGLER | 7 | The —, 1959 horror film starring Vincent Price and Judith Evelyn |
| 31% | BLOB | 4 | The —, 1988 horror film starring Kevin Dillon and Shawnee Smith |
| 31% | RING | 4 | The —, 2002 horror film starring Naomi Watts and Martin Henderson |
| 31% | OTHERS | 6 | The —, 2001 horror film starring Nicole Kidman and Fionnula Flanagan |
| 31% | HOWLING | 7 | The —, 1981 horror film starring Dee Wallace and Patrick Macnee |